The right repertoire for a choir is the one that sits just above what the group can already do on its own, without ever leaving that zone completely. A balanced programme mixes pieces the choir already knows, which bring pleasure and security, with one or two growth pieces, which make it progress. It is this balance, far more than the choice of any single piece, that decides whether people come back the following week.
This is the third article in the series on finding the right level in a choir. The first offered a scale for describing a choir, the second a method for reading how difficult a score is. What remains is to bring the two together.
The challenge that keeps people keen
When I asked colleagues how they assess a choir’s level, the most honest answer I got came down to one sentence: the whole art lies in finding something challenging while keeping people keen enough.
It’s true. And it’s hard, because the two aims pull in opposite directions. Too much challenge, and the choir spends the season learning notes without ever making music. Too much comfort, and it politely nods off, then quietly empties.
There is, however, a concept that helps us think about this balance. The psychologist Lev Vygotsky called it the zone of proximal development: the space between what a person can do alone and what they can do with help. It is in this zone, and only there, that learning happens. Below it, you repeat what you already know. Above it, nothing makes sense and you lose heart.
Applied to a choir, this gives a simple rule: a growth piece is a piece the group couldn’t put together on its own, but can put together through the work done in rehearsal. If the piece requires skills nobody in the room has yet, rehearsal won’t be enough. It’s no longer a challenge, it’s a wall.
A programme is not a single piece
The most common mistake is to assess each piece in isolation. This one is doable, so is that one, so is the third. And overall, the programme is unmanageable, because three doable but demanding pieces, placed end to end, leave no room to breathe.
A programme has to be thought of as a whole. It needs pieces the choir already knows or that sit comfortably in the voice, the ones you sing for pleasure and on which you can work on sound, dynamics and listening rather than notes. It needs one or two growth pieces, the ones that will make people say in June that they couldn’t have done this in September. And it needs at least one piece the singers really love, whatever its level.
That last point matters more than you might think. A piece people love pulls everything else along. You accept working hard on a demanding piece when you know you’ll then sing the one that moves you.
Du choriste au chœur
A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.
Discover the bookWhen should the difficult pieces come in the season?
Where a piece falls in the calendar matters as much as its level.
A growth piece introduced in May for a concert in June doesn’t stand a chance. It will be learnt in a rush, sung in fear, and it will be remembered as a failure even if the concert goes well. The same piece introduced in the autumn has time to mature, to be forgotten over the festive season, to come back in January and suddenly turn out to be easier than before. This settling time is part of learning; you can’t make up for it by adding rehearsals at the end.
Conversely, the pieces the choir already knows are precious at the end of the season, when tiredness sets in and the choir needs to feel good about itself.
Signs you’ve aimed too high
A repertoire that is too difficult can be seen before it is heard.
Rehearsals turn into note-bashing, section by section, and nobody ever talks about music any more. Singers no longer look up from their scores. Absences go up as the concert approaches instead of going down. The sound shrinks: everyone sings a little more quietly so as not to be heard making mistakes. And the same passage falls apart every time, in the same place, despite all the work.
That last sign is the most important. A passage that improves slowly is a challenge. A passage that doesn’t improve at all is a wall. The difference isn’t about difficulty, it’s about progress.
Signs you’ve aimed too low
A repertoire that is too easy can be spotted too, more discreetly.
Chatting while the other sections are working. Lateness creeping in, because nothing important happens in the first quarter of an hour. Singers who know their part by the second read-through and spend the rest of the term waiting. And that slightly limp energy, with no tension, where nobody takes risks because no risk is needed.
Be careful, though: an easy piece is never finished. A piece whose notes are learnt in one session can keep you busy for months working on sound, blend, tuning the chords, phrasing. If the choir is bored with a simple piece, it isn’t always the piece that is too easy. Sometimes it’s the work we offer on it that stops too soon.
Adapt rather than give up
Between keeping a piece that is too difficult and dropping it, there is a third way that is often forgotten: adapting it.
Transposing by a tone to get a section out of an uncomfortable zone. Sharing out an overly tortuous line between two sections. Simplifying a passage for part of the choir while keeping the original version for the strongest singers. Adding discreet instrumental support for the first few weeks, then taking it away. When I arrange a piece for a particular choir, this is exactly the work I do: keep what makes the music beautiful and remove whatever only serves to put the singers in difficulty.
Respecting a work doesn’t mean singing it badly as it stands. A simplified piece sung with conviction serves the music better than a complete version sung in anguish.
Involve the choir in the choice
Finally, the simplest way to keep people keen is still to ask them what they want to sing.
That doesn’t mean turning the choice of repertoire into a vote. The director remains responsible for the balance of the programme. But letting singers suggest pieces, listening to what moves them, explaining why you chose a particular difficult piece and what it will bring to the group: all of this radically changes the way the challenge is experienced. A challenge you understand is a project. A challenge imposed without explanation is a chore.
And what about the singers?
Everything above is mainly addressed to the person who chooses the programme. But a choir singer isn’t a spectator of that choice. They live it, one way or the other: some feel out of their depth with the repertoire, others are bored with pieces they knew within a week.
That is the subject of the next article, Too easy, too hard: the choir singer and their choir’s repertoire.
In the meantime, tell me in the comments which piece was the most memorable challenge for your choir, and what helped you rise to it, or not.
Share your thoughts on this article