A few weeks ago I received a message from an experienced choir singer who said: ‘Corentin, our conductor has given us a contemporary piece with chords I just can’t grasp. I feel as though I’ve lost all my bearings. How can I avoid looking ridiculous?’ This question touches me because it reveals a worry that many of you surely share. How can you calmly approach a repertoire that seems to escape the codes you’ve mastered?
Atonality, or more broadly contemporary music that breaks free of traditional tonal centres, can indeed be unsettling. But I’d like to suggest you see it differently: not as an insurmountable obstacle, but as a new colour to add to your vocal palette. A colour that may need a different kind of learning, but one that can enrich your experience as a choir singer in surprising ways.
Understanding it in order to tame it
Before we dive in at the deep end, let’s take time to understand what we’re talking about. Atonality isn’t necessarily that dissonant music that sets your teeth on edge. It is music that is no longer organised around a single tonal centre, a reference key. Imagine you usually sing in a house with a main living room around which everything revolves. Atonality is like discovering a house where every room is equally important, where you move freely from one space to another.
This approach has given rise to extraordinarily varied music. Some of it is indeed very dissonant and demanding; some is breathtakingly beautiful. Think of Ligeti’s washes of sound, the crystalline textures of Arvo Pärt in his most experimental periods, or the contemplative moments in Whitacre when he ventures off the beaten tonal track. These composers show us that atonality isn’t a three-headed monster but a musical language with its own rules and its own beauties.
In fact, you’re already approaching it without realising. When you sing certain passages of Poulenc, or even some jazz harmonies, you brush against areas where the key becomes hazier, more fluid. Atonality isn’t a completely foreign world; it’s more the logical continuation of a journey you’ve already begun.
The ear at the centre of everything
Your first ally when facing atonality is your ear. But not necessarily in the way you imagine. In tonal music, you rely on automatic reflexes: you hear a dominant chord, you know it’s going to resolve to the tonic. In atonal music, those landmarks disappear. It’s unsettling, but it’s also liberating.
You have to relearn how to listen. Instead of looking for the expected resolution, listen to the colours, the tensions, the contrasts. An interval of a major second can be magnificent in this context, where it would sound odd right in the middle of a Palestrina motet. Your ear will gradually get used to these new sounds, just as it got used to telling a major third from a minor third.
In practice, how do you go about it? Start by listening. A lot. Put on accessible atonal works in the background, without trying to understand everything straight away. Your brain will begin to make connections, to create new landmarks. That is exactly what happened when you discovered choral singing: at first, distinguishing your line from the others was quite a feat; today it’s natural.
Next, work on intervals. Not in a cold, theoretical way, but by exploring their expressive colours. Sing a minor second feeling it as a gentle tension, an augmented fourth as a mysterious opening. These intervals, which tonal music uses sparingly, become fully fledged expressive tools in atonal music.
Technique in the service of exploration
Rest assured, your vocal technique remains your solid foundation. Just because the harmony changes doesn’t mean you have to reinvent everything. On the contrary, well-grounded technique gives you the freedom to explore these new musical territories without tensing up.
Let’s start with tuning. In atonal music, being in tune becomes more relative, but it is no less crucial. Only, instead of locking on to a tonal centre, you have to tune to the other voices in real time. It’s an exercise in constant listening, which demands great availability. Make sure your breath support is well in place, because you’ll need all your concentration to adjust your intonation according to what you hear around you.
Entries become particularly important. In an atonal context, a woolly entry can compromise the building of a chord. Work on balanced onsets, the ones that allow a precise start without harshness. It’s all the more crucial because you don’t always have the usual tonal landmarks to catch you if you slip.
Vocal flexibility also takes on a new dimension. In atonal music, you’ll find yourself singing unusual intervals, sometimes melodic leaps that are outside your habits. Work on your chromatic scales, your controlled glissandos. The idea isn’t to become a virtuoso of contemporary singing overnight, but to develop the agility needed to navigate these less familiar waters.
Du choriste au chœur
A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.
Discover the bookPractical strategies for your own practice
When you find yourself facing an atonal score, don’t panic. Take a gradual, almost exploratory approach. Start by spotting the elements you recognise: familiar rhythms, melodic shapes that speak to you, dynamics you’ve already mastered.
Then work on your part note by note, without trying to understand the whole straight away. It’s a bit like learning a foreign language: you start with single words before building sentences. Sing each note placing it carefully, listening to it resonate. Little by little, fragments of musical sense will emerge.
Don’t hesitate to use a reference instrument, even if the final aim is to sing a cappella. A piano or an app on your phone can help you check your intervals, especially at first. That isn’t cheating, it’s a learning tool. You’ll naturally wean yourself off it once your ear is more at ease.
A technique I’m particularly fond of: record yourself singing your line, then listen back while you play another section’s line on the piano. It helps you grasp how your part fits with the whole, even in an atonal context. You begin to perceive the internal logic of the work, its own particular balances.
And give yourself the right not to understand everything immediately. Atonality takes time to tame. Some passages will resist you for weeks before suddenly becoming clear. That’s normal; it’s even exciting. You are broadening your musical world, and that doesn’t happen at the snap of your fingers.
The collective approach: when the choir discovers together
Atonality takes on a particular dimension in a choir. In an ensemble, individual difficulties can multiply, but so can resources. You’re no longer alone facing this mysterious score: you have companions in the adventure.
The first step is often to take the drama out of it as a group. Ask your conductor to explain the background of the work, what is at stake expressively, what drove the composer. When you understand that a dissonant passage expresses suffering, or that unstable harmonies convey anxiety, you approach them with more confidence. Atonal music isn’t gratuitous; it has its reasons for being, its intentions.
In rehearsal, accept taking your time. Atonal music is worked on differently from tonal music. Your conductor may have you sing the chords vertically, section by section, so that you hear how they are built. Take part in this collective exploration, even if it seems laborious at first.
Listening to one another becomes crucial. Without traditional tonal landmarks, you need to develop finer listening to the other parts. It’s demanding, but it’s also formative. This heightened attention to the other voices will enrich your choral practice in general, even when you go back to Mozart or Fauré.
Don’t hesitate to ask questions during rehearsals. ‘How should I be hearing this interval?’ ‘Is my note in tune with the altos?’ These questions don’t reveal incompetence; they show your commitment to the learning process.
Getting past your apprehensions
I know some of you are thinking: ‘But why make life complicated? There’s so much magnificent tonal music to explore!’ And you’re right, there is. But atonality isn’t there to replace Palestrina or Bach; it comes to enrich your palette, to offer you other means of expression.
Think of your journey as a choir singer. At the start, perhaps even a simple triad seemed complex. Today you find your way through four-part polyphony without difficulty. Atonality is the same thing: a territory that seems inaccessible to you today but which can become familiar with practice and patience.
And then there’s that particular satisfaction of mastering something difficult. When you manage to sing a complex atonal passage in tune, when you feel you are helping to create that very particular sound, you’ll feel a legitimate pride. It’s the same pleasure as pulling off a virtuoso passage in a Vivaldi concerto, but with the extra flavour of exploration.
Atonality can also reveal unexpected aspects of your voice. Those unusual intervals, those new harmonic colours can make your instrument resonate in surprising ways. Some singers discover facets of their timbre they never suspected when they take on this repertoire.
Bridges between tradition and modernity
A common mistake is to set tonal and atonal music against each other as two incompatible worlds. In reality, there are many bridges between them. Many contemporary composers, even when they venture into atonality, keep tonal elements: centres of attraction, deflected cadences, echoes of ancient modality.
In Whitacre, for example, you find moments where the harmony floats between tonality and atonality, creating magnificent effects of light. These works are excellent springboards for approaching atonality without a brutal break from your habits. They let you keep one foot in the familiar while exploring the unknown.
Even in more radically atonal composers, you often find internal logic that recalls classical principles: build-ups of tension, releases, echoes between the voices. These familiar structures can serve as your thread through a disorienting harmonic labyrinth.
That is in fact one of the fascinating aspects of atonality: it forces you to rediscover musical elements you took for granted. Melodic shapes, rhythms, timbres take on new importance when traditional harmony fades away. You develop finer listening, more attentive to detail.
Du choriste au chœur
A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.
Discover the bookBuilding your confidence step by step
Confidence with atonality can’t be decreed; it is built little by little. Start with accessible works, composers who manage the transitions between the familiar and the new. Don’t throw yourself straight into wall-to-wall Schoenberg: you might get discouraged.
Celebrate your small victories. The day you manage to sing a difficult interval first time, when you feel you’re contributing harmoniously to a complex chord, savour that moment. This apparently modest progress is in fact a giant leap in your musical development.
Accept, too, that some works will resist you more than others. As in tonal music, you’ll have your affinities and your difficulties. Some passages will speak to you immediately; others will take months to tame. That’s the normal process of making a musical language your own.
Don’t forget that what you feel matters. If an atonal sound moves you, even without your understanding why, trust yourself. Music sometimes reaches our sensibility by roundabout routes, independently of our intellectual understanding. That direct emotion is often the best guide to approaching these repertoires.
And bear in mind that you don’t have to like all atonal music. Even the most open-minded music lovers have their preferences, their areas of resistance. What matters is keeping a kindly curiosity and not closing the door on principle.
Towards a fulfilling practice
In the end, atonality is just one expressive tool among others. A tool that requires specific learning, admittedly, but one that can considerably enrich your experience as a choir singer. It gives you access to particular emotional colours, to unique musical sensations.
Approaching it with confidence means first accepting that it works by different rules from the ones you’ve mastered. It means showing patience and curiosity. It also means relying on the technique you’ve acquired while staying open to new approaches.
Your voice remains your instrument, with its own qualities and characteristics. Atonality won’t transform it radically; rather, it will reveal other facets of its expressive possibilities. It’s a journey of exploration, not a revolution.
And who knows? Perhaps one day you’ll catch yourself humming an atonal passage as you leave rehearsal, because it touched you with its strange beauty. Perhaps you’ll discover in a contemporary composer a sensibility that echoes your own. Atonality isn’t hostile territory; it’s a musical continent to explore, with its austere landscapes and its moments of unexpected grace.
In the meantime, keep singing, keep exploring, keep trusting yourself. Your voice knows how to adapt, your ear knows how to learn, your heart knows how to recognise beauty, even when it takes roundabout paths. Atonality is just one more stage on your journey as a choir singer, a stage that can turn out to be fascinating if you approach it with an open mind and the generosity you already bring to music.
Corentin
Share your thoughts on this article