A few weeks ago, in one of my workshops, someone started to cry.

Not from pain. Not from shame. More like something letting go, that deep sigh you have been holding in for far too long. We had just sung together for two hours. People who hadn’t known each other an hour earlier, voices you wouldn’t have expected to hear. And at the end of the session, this person said to me, eyes red: ‘It’s the first time anyone has really let me sing.’

I didn’t know what to say. I just thought it was a shame. That it shouldn’t be so rare.

I often replay that scene in my head. Because it says something fundamental about the relationship we have, in France, with singing together. And it brings me back to a question that has occupied me for years: why do we judge ourselves so harshly when we sing?

The voice is not an instrument like any other

When a violinist misses a note, they can blame the bow, the instrument, the humidity in the hall. When a pianist plays a wrong note, they can talk about the tuning, the action, tired keys. The voice allows no such distance. It comes out of you. It is you.

This is what we call the intimacy of the voice, and this is where everything gets complicated. The voice is a reflection of personality. You can’t swap instruments when it doesn’t sound right, you can’t put it down on a shelf between two phrases. It’s there, exposed, fragile, recognisable. And when someone criticises it, even indirectly, even with all the kindness in the world, it’s a part of us they are touching.

This reality explains a great deal of what I have been observing for years as a conductor. It explains why some seasoned choir singers resist every correction, not out of ill will but out of a protective instinct. It explains why people who can sing perfectly well fall apart at the thought of standing alone in front of a group. And it explains why kindness, in choral singing, is neither a luxury nor a comfort: it is a working condition.

The two extremes I meet every week

My everyday life as a musician puts me in a rather unusual position, because I work at both ends of the spectrum at once.

On one side, I direct a vocal ensemble in Paris. Seasoned singers who read music and are used to contemporary a cappella repertoire. Accomplished musicians, amateurs in the noblest sense of the word, who often have several years, sometimes several decades, of choral singing behind them. Serious, committed, passionate people.

And yet, at every rehearsal, I wrestle with something I might not have expected: the ego. That dull, diffuse resistance, sometimes barely conscious. That tendency to put your voice above the chord, to shine where you ought to blend, to defend your sonic territory rather than let the collective music flow through you. It isn’t ill will. It isn’t arrogance. It’s being human. The ego protects what is precious, and the voice is precious.

On the other side, in my workshops, I regularly meet people who tell me as they arrive: ‘I’m not sure I’m in the right place, I’m a really bad singer.’ And then they sing for two hours. With musicality, real listening, phrasing, a sensitivity you can’t manufacture. Everything you look for in a choir singer. Except confidence.

These two profiles, which look like opposites, actually have the same thing in common: they think of themselves first. One to defend themselves, the other to put themselves down. Both look at their own voice before they look at the shared sound.

When technique isn’t enough

A few years ago, I went to a concert with six soloists from the Paris Opera. Well-known names, trained voices, professionals who sing in major opera houses, people who have been working on polyphony for years. A fine line-up, technically speaking.

The result was disappointing.

Not in terms of the individual voices. Each one did their job, produced the expected sounds, held the notes. But they sang straight ahead. Six individuals on stage, each in their own bubble of sound, each carrying their voice like a trophy. That wasn’t polyphony any more. It was six simultaneous monologues.

Polyphony can’t be improvised, even with the most beautiful voices in the world. Perhaps especially with the most beautiful voices in the world. Because the more a voice has been worked on, the more personality it has, and the more work, desire and humility it takes to blend it into a collective texture. Vocal technique is a tool. It doesn’t replace listening. It doesn’t replace the relationship with others. And when it becomes an end in itself, when it becomes the centre of gravity of a choral performance, the collective sound suffers immediately.

I was still thinking about it weeks after that concert. Because it is the exact counter-example of something we often believe: that the stronger you are technically, the better you will be in a choir. That isn’t always true. What makes a great choir singer is, first and foremost, the ability to listen, to adjust, to disappear into the shared sound when necessary. And you can’t buy that ability in private lessons.

The book

Du choriste au chœur

A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.

Discover the book

Polyphony without qualifications

I often think of the folk polyphony choirs you find in Colombia or Argentina. Groups where nobody reads music in the academic sense. Ordinary voices that have never been to a conservatoire, that couldn’t name an interval, that sing their parts by ear, by transmission, for pleasure.

The shivers are there. Every time.

These people listen to each other in a way I rarely see in trained ensembles. They sing for one another, constantly attentive to what the group is producing. They have nothing to prove, so they don’t try to prove anything. And out of that absence of showing off comes something powerful, something technique alone can’t produce.

This isn’t an argument against training. I’m the first to believe that understanding what you do improves what you produce. But it is a reminder that choral music has an intelligence of its own, which comes before theory and will outlive it. That intelligence is listening.

What Edward Caswell says

In his book ‘C’est comme caresser un chat’ (‘It’s like stroking a cat’), the choir director Edward Caswell tells his singers, in essence: if you sing in a choir with me, you don’t need to take individual lessons elsewhere, because everything you would learn there, he is already telling you in rehearsals.

That sentence has stayed with me ever since I read it, and it says something essential about what choral conducting can be at its best. A good choir director is first and foremost a singer. A good choir director is a teacher who teaches from inside the sound, in the movement, in the shared moment. Not in technical abstractions, not in vocal theories, but in the very flesh of working together.

That is what led me not to give individual lessons. Not for lack of interest in the voice, but because what fundamentally interests me is polyphony. It’s connection. It’s the question of how my voice sounds next to my neighbour’s, how two timbres that have nothing in common can suddenly find a chord that goes beyond them both. That kind of alchemy can’t be taught alone in a room.

My stepfather couldn’t sing to save his life

That isn’t unkind, it’s a fact. He sang badly, he knew it, he laughed about it. But someone let him sing. Someone didn’t tell him he was in the wrong place. He kept going, he found himself in groups that welcomed him as he was. And today he performs at open mic nights. I’m not going to sign him up for a TV talent show. But he enjoys himself, and he passes that enjoyment on. The audience can feel it. It’s real.

What I take from his story is that the transformation came not from intensive technical work but from a space where he was allowed to be imperfect. Mistakes weren’t punished. Progress was welcome, not demanded. And in that space, his voice found its place.

That, at heart, is what I would like for French choirs. Not lower standards. But more room.

The right to be imperfect is not a concession

I’m not campaigning for a choir where nothing matters, where nobody works, where a vague sense of enjoyment excuses a lack of commitment. Choral singing is demanding. It requires regularity, concentration, preparation. It requires you to come with your parts learnt, to respect the group, to understand that what is at stake is bigger than you.

But high standards and kindness are not enemies.

You can ask a lot and still leave room to get things wrong. You can have high standards and welcome someone who is just starting out. You can build a rigorous collective sound in an atmosphere where people aren’t keeping an eye on each other to see who is singing out of tune.

France has a particular tradition when it comes to singing together. Choral singing was long confined to institutional, religious or academic spaces, far from the spontaneous popular practices that exist in other countries. That history has created a certain idea of the ‘good’ singer, of the required level, of the road you have to travel before you are allowed to sing with others. And that idea does silent damage. It fills workshops with beginners who apologise for being there. It empties choirs of voices that would have belonged there if only they had been let in.

What makes the difference

The question I ask myself more and more is not ‘how do I recruit good choir singers?’ It is ‘how do I create spaces where people want to improve?’

They are not the same question.

The first selects. The second includes. And inclusion, in choral singing, often produces results you didn’t expect. Because a voice that feels safe sings better than a voice on the defensive. Because a singer who isn’t afraid of getting it wrong takes musical risks that enrich the collective sound. Because the ego, once it no longer needs to protect itself, can at last put itself at the service of the music.

I have seen gospel choirs where nobody reads music and whose concerts are deeply moving. I have seen a cappella groups of average singers produce something moving through the quality of their attention to one another. I have seen wonderful soloists fail completely at polyphony because they had never learnt to listen.

Level isn’t the main variable. Listening is.

The book

Du choriste au chœur

A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.

Discover the book

Kindness goes both ways

We often talk about a choir director’s kindness towards the singers. That’s legitimate, it’s important, it’s even fundamental. But we almost always forget the other direction.

Kindness, in a choir that really works, goes in every direction. It flows between the singers, of course. It is built between one section and another, between an old hand and a beginner, between someone who sings in tune and someone still looking for their note. It also concerns each singer’s attitude towards themselves, that ability to give yourself the right to progress without judging yourself at every bar.

But it must also go towards the person standing at the front.

A choir director is a musician. Often a music professional, sometimes a passionate amateur, always someone who has put a lot of themselves into the role. Not a psychology professional. Not someone who turns up every Monday evening with their emotions perfectly tidied away and their teaching calibrated to the millimetre. They have difficult days. They sometimes arrive tired, sometimes preoccupied, sometimes with words that come out less well than they would like. They can make mistakes. They can phrase a correction clumsily, choose the wrong moment to insist on something, miss a tension in the group.

That isn’t an excuse. It’s a reality.

The relationship between a choir director and the singers is a relationship of trust, and like every relationship of trust, it is built in both directions. A singer who can give their director the benefit of the doubt, who can tell a clumsy remark from a hurtful criticism, who understands that the person in front of them is carrying the music, the group and their own human tiredness all at once: that singer helps to create a space where everyone can work better.

I’m not saying you should accept everything. I’m saying that a choir that works is not a choir with a perfect director. It is a choir where mutual trust is solid enough to get through the imperfect moments without everything collapsing.

What I simply hope for

There are choirs for every level. Demanding ensembles that recruit by audition and build ambitious programmes. Discovery workshops that welcome everyone, no questions asked. Neighbourhood groups that sing for the pleasure of it and nothing else. That diversity is a strength, not a problem.

The question is never ‘am I good enough?’ It is always ‘am I going to the right place?’

But for that question to have an answer, the places have to exist. Choirs have to present themselves clearly for what they are. Directors have to say honestly what they are looking for. Doors have to be genuinely open where they claim to be. And behind those doors, people must have the right to get things wrong, to be off the mark, to move forward at their own pace, without someone, somewhere, looking at them with that mixture of impatience and condescension that drives voices away before they have had time to blossom.

The person who cried in my workshop had a beautiful voice. They didn’t know it yet. All they had been missing was a place where they were allowed to let it out.

Corentin