You’ve sung some Bach before, haven’t you? And you may have had that strange feeling: on the one hand it’s fearsomely complex, on the other it seems to flow quite naturally, as if the music were building itself. That impression is no accident. Johann Sebastian Bach had a special genius for making something that is in fact extraordinarily sophisticated harmonically seem simple.
Today we’re going to look together at a concrete example: the closing chorale of the cantata BWV 4, ‘Christ lag in Todesbanden’. Don’t worry, we’re not going to do any slapdash musicological analysis. Our aim is to understand how Bach shapes his chords so that you, as choir singers, can better feel what’s going on beneath your feet when you sing his music.

Bach’s harmonic genius: when every note finds its place
Bach didn’t invent the chorale melodies. The Lutheran tunes existed long before him, some of them since the Middle Ages. His job was to clothe them in harmony, and that’s where his mastery shines. Take ‘Christ lag in Todesbanden’: the melody you sing in the soprano part dates back to the sixteenth century. Bach turns it into an architecture of sound.
The triad as a solid foundation
It all starts with the basics: the triad, the three-note chord that forms the backbone of tonal music. In our chorale in E minor, Bach uses the tonic chord (E-G-B) in root position, of course, but also inverted. You know that moment when the bass doesn’t make the leap of a fifth you’d expect? That’s often Bach choosing a first inversion (G in the bass) so that the bass line stays smooth.
That smoothness is vital for us as singers. When the bass moves by step rather than by leap, the harmony glides naturally from one chord to the next. You can feel it: some passages of Bach literally ‘flow’, as if each chord were calling for the next.
Inversions: the art of stepwise movement
Bach keeps second-inversion chords (the famous six-four) for very specific moments. Often it’s in cadences, those moments of harmonic punctuation that mark the end of a musical phrase. You know the cadential six-four: it comes before the dominant and creates that tension which urgently demands resolution.
When you sing these passages, notice how your voice takes part in this mechanism. If you’re an alto holding the dissonant fourth, you can feel that your note ‘wants’ to go down. Bach exploits this natural tendency of intervals to create musical movement.
Harmonic enrichment: when dissonances become beauties
Dominant sevenths: tension and resolution
Bach isn’t content with simple triads. He constantly enriches his chords, notably with sevenths. The most common is the dominant seventh. In ‘Christ lag in Todesbanden’, watch what happens when the B7 chord arrives (the dominant with its seventh, the A). That note creates a tension that needs to fall a semitone to the G of the E minor chord that follows.
That’s exactly what Bach does: he turns this technical constraint into expressive beauty. The seventh isn’t there by chance; it draws a logical melodic line in the bass or in the inner parts.
Chromatic alterations: colours and modulations
But Bach goes further. He brings in chromatic alterations that don’t belong to the home key. In our chorale, you’ll see an A♯ appear, a note foreign to E minor. This A♯ turns the F♯ chord into the dominant of B major (the dominant of the dominant, if you prefer). This is what we call a secondary dominant.
For you as singers, these alterations are precious: they colour your singing and prepare changes of key. When you sing that A♯, you’re taking part in a harmonic journey that will take us away from E minor for a moment, the better to come back to it.
Du choriste au chœur
A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.
Discover the bookVoice leading: when every line has a life of its own
This is perhaps where Bach’s greatest genius lies: every part, from soprano to bass, has its own melodic logic while contributing to the overall harmony. You’re never just ‘chord notes’. You’re independent melodies in conversation.
Why the inner parts matter
Altos and tenors, you who sometimes feel forgotten between the soprano tune and the foundation of the bass, think again! In Bach, you’re essential. You fill in the intervals, you create passing lines, you add rhythmic embellishments that bring the harmony to life.
In ‘Christ lag in Todesbanden’, notice how your parts often move by step, softening the leaps in the bass and avoiding harmonic gaps. You’re the weavers of this tapestry of sound.
Handling dissonance: preparation and resolution
Bach treats dissonances with extreme care. With him, a dissonance rarely comes out of nowhere: it is prepared. The suspension is the perfect example. One voice holds on to a note from the previous chord while the others change harmony, creating a momentary dissonance that then resolves by step.
If you’re singing a 4-3 suspension (the fourth resolving to a third), you feel physically the need for that resolution. Your note ‘pulls’ downwards, and when you resolve it, it’s as if the tension were released. Bach exploits these natural sensations to create his expressive language.
The art of contrary motion
To avoid forbidden parallels (the parallel fifths and octaves that weaken the independence of the voices), Bach constantly uses contrary motion. When one voice goes up, the other comes down. Far from being a dry constraint, in his hands this technique becomes a source of melodic beauty.
When you sing Bach, pay attention to these movements: they create an inner momentum that carries the music forward.
Harmonic journeys: modulations and homecomings
The circle of fifths as a guide
‘Christ lag in Todesbanden’ stays broadly in E minor, but Bach takes us travelling within that key. He uses a harmonic path that follows the logic of the circle of fifths: E minor → A minor → D major → G major → C major → F♯ diminished → B major → back to E minor.
This progression creates the illusion of wide harmonic exploration, when in reality we never really stray far from the tonal centre. It’s like a walk that takes us to the top of a hill, only to bring us back down home.
Pivot chords: smooth transitions
To carry out these modulations, Bach uses pivot chords, chords that belong both to the starting key and to the key of arrival. An E minor chord can be the tonic in E minor, but also the sixth degree in G major. Depending on the harmonic context that follows, our ear tips towards one reading or the other.
These pivots make the modulations natural, imperceptible. You don’t feel a break, just a colour gradually changing.
Secondary dominants: harmonic windows
Secondary dominants are the chords that temporarily prepare a new key. Bach uses them sparingly but effectively. In our chorale, the F♯ major chord with its A♯ prepares the arrival in B major. It’s a window opening onto a new tonal landscape before closing again.
For you as singers, these moments are precious: they bring unexpected colours to your singing and often mark strongly expressive moments in the text.
Modal borrowings: when old and new talk to each other
The tierce de Picardie: acoustics and symbolism
Bach composed within the tonal system of his day, but he didn’t forget the old modes from which the Lutheran chorales came. ‘Christ lag in Todesbanden’ in E minor ends on an E major chord. That final G♯, that tierce de Picardie, doesn’t belong to the natural E minor scale: it’s borrowed from the major mode.
But why was this practice so widespread in the Baroque era? There’s a fascinating acoustic reason: in the large churches where this music rang out, minor thirds create unpleasant beats with the natural harmonics of the sound. The acoustics of the vaults amplify certain frequencies, and the minor third, with its mathematical ratios less ‘pure’ than those of the major third, produces troubling interference.
The major third, with its frequency ratio of 5:4, fits perfectly into the natural harmonic series. In a church, it resonates fully, without the micro-beats that make a chord unstable. That’s why even a piece clearly in a minor mode often ended on this major chord: not only for expressive reasons (light after darkness), but also for purely acoustic ones.
So this tierce de Picardie brings both a symbolic light, perfectly suited to an Easter text celebrating the victory of life over death, and an acoustic stability that lets the final chord resonate as fully as possible in the sacred space. Bach never does anything by chance: every harmonic choice serves both the expression of the text and the acoustic constraints of the performance space.
Dorian colours: respecting the heritage
The original chorale ‘Christ lag in Todesbanden’ is in the Dorian mode. While harmonising it tonally, Bach sometimes keeps traces of this ancient mode. Using C natural instead of the C♯ you’d expect in E minor evokes this particular modal colour.
These modal borrowings aren’t archaisms: they enrich Bach’s expressive palette and give his chorales that depth in time which lets old and new speak to each other.
Du choriste au chœur
A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.
Discover the bookCadences: punctuation and breathing
The perfect cadence: full stop
A perfect cadence (dominant to tonic, with both chords in root position) closes our chorale. B major to E major, with E in the soprano: it’s the logical outcome of the whole harmonic journey. This cadence brings a feeling of total completion, of full resolution.
But Bach doesn’t keep the perfect cadence just for the end. He can use it in secondary keys to mark important stages in the musical journey.
Imperfect cadences: suspension and momentum
Subtler are the imperfect cadences, the formulas that stop on the dominant without resolving. They create a feeling of suspension that calls for what comes next. In ‘Christ lag in Todesbanden’, some phrases end this way, keeping up the musical momentum and avoiding the monotony of one complete resolution after another.
The Phrygian cadence: modal colour
Particularly expressive in a minor context, the Phrygian cadence moves the bass down a semitone (from the subdominant in first inversion to the dominant). This progression recalls the old modes and brings a particularly plaintive colour, well suited to religious texts.
Bach often uses it in the penultimate phrase of a chorale, creating one last tension before the triumphant final resolution.
Why Bach still moves us today
The balance between rule and expression
What’s fascinating about Bach is that perfect balance between technical mastery and expressiveness. Every chord obeys the rules of tonal harmony, but every succession of chords tells us something. Technique is never an end in itself: it always serves the expression of the text and the musical emotion.
An architecture of sound
Bach’s chorales are true architectures of sound. Every element has its place and its function: the foundations (the bass), the load-bearing structure (the harmony), the ornaments (the chromatic passages), the openings (the modulations). Everything works together to create a coherent, expressive musical building.
The spiritual dimension
Let’s not forget that Bach was composing for the Lutheran Church. His chorales aren’t mere harmony exercises: they carry the faith and emotions of a community. This spiritual dimension shows through in every musical choice, in every harmonic progression that highlights a word of the text or a theological idea.
Taking it further in your choral singing
Listen actively to the harmony
When you sing Bach, don’t just follow your own melodic line. Listen to the whole chord, feel the tensions and resolutions, notice the harmonic colours changing. This active listening will greatly enrich your experience of choral singing.
Understand your harmonic role
Every note you sing has a harmonic function: root, third, fifth, seventh… Understanding that function helps you blend your voice better into the whole and adapt your vocal production accordingly.
Breathe with the harmonic phrases
Breaths taken together in a choir shouldn’t only follow the text: they should also respect the harmonic phrases. Taking a breath in the middle of a cadential progression breaks the musical momentum. Learn to feel these long harmonic breaths.
Work on intonation in a harmonic context
Intonation in a cappella polyphony is different from the tempered tuning of the piano. Some intervals need adjusting for the chord to sound fully. Develop your harmonic ear to perceive the micro-adjustments that make the difference between a chord that sounds and a chord that sings.
This exploration of Bach’s harmony is only a beginning. Every Bach chorale holds harmonic treasures that deserve to be discovered and savoured. The more you understand these mechanisms, the more musicality and expressiveness your singing will gain. Because that’s the real goal: not to become harmony theorists, but to become more aware singers, more musical, better able to make these architectures of sound that Bach left us vibrate together.
Bach’s harmony isn’t a technical straitjacket: it’s a living language, a means of expression that still moves us three centuries after it was created. By understanding this language better, you don’t just become better performers: you become heirs to an extraordinary musical tradition, interpreters of a heritage that unites technique and emotion, rule and freedom, the human and the divine.
Share your thoughts on this article