A summer festival, an abbey church, a slightly wobbly rush-seated chair, and on the stage a choir you don’t know. You’re sitting down, you have nothing to do, and that’s when it starts: after two minutes, you’re no longer listening to the music.

You’re counting the tenors. You’ve spotted the soprano on the right who is starting to lose her grip a little. You notice that the start of the second movement was ragged. You wonder how they solved the problem in bar 7.

Don’t feel guilty. It isn’t a flaw, it’s a privilege. A choir singer doesn’t listen to a concert the way the person next to them in the row does, and that kind of listening, if you organise it a little, is probably the best tool for progress you have all summer.

It costs nothing, it doesn’t tire your voice, and it teaches you things no rehearsal can teach you, for the simple reason that in rehearsal, you are inside it.

You never hear your own choir

This is the starting point, and it is more unsettling than it seems. You may have been singing in the same ensemble for fifteen years, and you have never heard it.

You hear what reaches your ears from inside the row: your own voice, very loud, your two neighbours’ voices, a little, and the rest, very far away, distorted.

The sound the audience receives, you only know from recordings, which is to say badly. It’s a strange situation when you think about it: the result of your work is, by its very structure, out of your reach.

A summer concert is a chance to sit on the other side and listen to what actually reaches an audience when a choir sings. Not your choir, but a choir. And what reaches them is almost always different from what you imagine from inside the row.

The book

Du choriste au chœur

A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.

Discover the book

Three things you can hear that you never suspected

The first is that volume doesn’t carry. When you sing, you think power is what projects. From the audience, you discover it isn’t. What gets through, what reaches the tenth row, is the consonants and the clarity of the vowels.

A choir that articulates while singing at half strength can be perfectly audible; a choir that pushes can be mush. Once you have made that discovery from a pew, it changes the way you sing for good.

The second is that slips in ensemble are very audible. In rehearsal, you feel that everyone starts more or less together.

From the audience, a ragged entry is immediately noticeable, and it gives a sense of uncertainty that spreads to everything that follows. Conversely, a choir that isn’t particularly brilliant but whose entries are clean gives an impression of complete control.

The third, the most interesting: what you remember from a concert is almost never technical. You will leave remembering a silence, a colour in one particular piece, a singer’s expression, the way a phrase was allowed to die away.

You won’t remember the intonation. That’s worth knowing when you spend six months working on nothing else.

Watch what isn’t the music

While you’re there, make the most of it and observe what you can never see from your place in the row.

Look at the faces. Do the people look as though they are really there? A technically flawless choir whose twenty faces are buried in their scores produces polite boredom.

A less precise choir whose singers look at each other, breathe together and clearly have something to say will carry a whole audience with them. It’s unfair, and it’s reality.

Watch how they come on, how they take their places, how they hold the silence between two pieces. How they react when something goes wrong, because something always goes wrong. That is where an ensemble’s professionalism is really decided, far more than in the notes.

And watch the person conducting, asking yourself what exactly they are doing. You will often see that they do much less than you imagined. The best gestures are small.

What you take home

Nothing immediate, and that’s fine. Summer listening isn’t a course. It leaves things behind in you, and those things resurface in September without your knowing where they came from.

But if you want to get something concrete out of it, take thirty seconds after the concert and write down just one sentence: what worked, and why. Not three pages. One sentence.

The silence after the last piece, held four seconds longer than usual. The way they launched into the a cappella motet after an accompanied piece. Details like these, you will bring back to your own choir without even putting them into words.

And there is one last benefit, a quieter one. Listening to another choir reminds you why you do this.

In August, when rehearsals are still a long way off and motivation is low, an hour in an abbey church listening to twenty people singing together is often enough to rekindle the desire better than any resolution.

Do you go to concerts in the summer? Tell me in the comments about the best thing you heard this year: I’d love to know.