One Monday evening, on my way home from rehearsal, I was still turning the same question over in my mind. I had a piece in mind, a beautiful piece, and I couldn’t work out whether the choir in front of me could sing it. Was I looking for the right voices for a piece, or the right piece for the voices I had? And I caught myself thinking: if only there were a benchmark for level that everyone could agree on.

The next morning, I came across one.

The Lyon-based choir director Zana Zaganjori had just published a scale of choir levels, from A1 to C2. I didn’t design it, she did, and she had only just shared it. Her work is what sparked this series.

Assessing a choir’s level means looking separately at several skills that don’t progress at the same pace: reading music, collective intonation, the ability to hold your line among the others, vocal technique and familiarity with a repertoire. None of these skills on its own is enough to say where an ensemble stands. That’s why the question is so hard, and that’s why a tool like Zana’s was missing.

Why I’m writing this series

The question that Monday evening wasn’t new. For years I’ve been putting it to colleagues. On courses, in training sessions, in the corridors after a concert. How do you assess a choir’s level? Not a singer’s, a choir’s.

And for years I’ve been getting roughly the same three answers. The first sidesteps the question: you don’t assess the choir, you assess the scores you can give it. The second closes it down: that’s experience, it’ll come with time. The third is the most accurate and the most frustrating at the same time: the whole job is finding pieces that are a challenge without people losing the desire to come.

None of these answers is wrong. But none of them is a tool. When you have to choose a programme on a Monday evening for a concert in June, you don’t need wisdom, you need something you can apply.

The question also haunts me for another reason. I conduct, but I also compose and arrange for choirs. Every score I write poses the same problem the other way round: who am I writing for, and what can those people actually sing? Reading Zana’s scale, I thought that at last there was a way to talk about it in shared terms, and that the time had come to write down what this question has had me thinking about for years.

This series runs to five articles. This one presents Zana’s scale. The second looks at what makes a score genuinely difficult. The third deals with choosing repertoire and finding the right challenge. The fourth takes the singers’ side, faced with a piece that’s too easy or too hard. The last tackles the most common case of all, the choir where every level rubs shoulders. It’s aimed at people who conduct, but also at choir singers, because the question concerns them at least as much.

Why is a choir’s level so hard to assess?

Because a choir doesn’t have one level, it has a dozen, and they don’t move together.

There’s reading: how many people can discover their line on the page by themselves. There’s collective intonation, which has almost nothing to do with reading. There’s the ability to hold your part when the neighbouring section is singing something else right beside you. There’s vocal technique, stamina. And there’s the repertoire in which the group feels at home.

A choir can read like a seasoned ensemble and still drop a semitone in a slow a cappella piece. Another may not read at all and sound magnificent in what it has learnt by ear. When you ask what the level is, you’re really asking ten questions in one. Experience is the ability to answer all ten without having to put them into words.

The trouble is that experience can’t be handed on. It builds up slowly, through mistakes. And while you’re building it up, you choose the wrong programme.

The book

Du choriste au chœur

A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.

Discover the book

What is a scale of choir levels for?

The question rarely comes up in the abstract. It crops up at specific moments: when you stand in for someone in front of a choir you’ve never heard and have to decide in ten minutes what you’re going to work on; when you’re looking for an arrangement and want to be sure it will be doable before you’ve handed out the copies; when you’re a choir singer looking for an ensemble where you won’t be bored but won’t drown either; when you ask a colleague for advice and first have to describe your choir in three sentences.

In all these cases, what’s missing isn’t intuition. It’s a shared vocabulary. That’s what a scale is for, first and foremost: being able to tell someone else what you’re hearing.

Zana Zaganjori’s scale, from A1 to C2

Zana Zaganjori conducts choirs in Lyon, sings, composes, arranges and teaches. With friends from the choral world, she kept running into the same problem as me, and she was the one who had the idea of turning it into a tool. Her scale borrows the grading of the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages, the CEFR, which everyone has come across at school or in a language course: six levels, from A1 to C2.

It’s a clever choice. Rather than inventing yet another grid, she borrows a grading people already know and fills it with what matters in a choir: the ability to sing more or less complex polyphony, reading music, vocal technique, stage presence and an embodied knowledge of a particular musical field.

In short, in my words rather than hers, the A levels describe choirs discovering polyphony, first with no reading at all, then able to follow a score without really reading it. The B levels mark the arrival of reading, partial and then independent, with increasingly solid foundations in technique and presence. The C levels describe pre-professional and then professional ensembles, who sight-read and have an in-depth knowledge of their repertoire.

Zana makes two points that I find essential. It is neither a value judgement nor a way of putting people in boxes. And you can perfectly well find yourself between two levels, with some criteria counting more than others depending on the group.

The full scale, with its descriptions, is on her website (in French): zanazaganjori.com/echelle-de-niveaux-des-choeurs. Go and read it there rather than relying on my summary.

Stage presence, a criterion apart

Under Zana’s post, one comment caught my eye. Someone pointed out that many professionals are excellent singers and yet far from comfortable when it comes to stage presence. That’s true, and I’d go further: personally, I’d take that criterion out of the scale.

Not because presence doesn’t matter. It matters enormously in concert. But it says nothing about what a choir can sing. An ensemble can sight-read, keep perfect intonation in a difficult a cappella piece, and stay frozen on stage. Another can radiate and come unstuck at the first awkward interval. Mixing the two into one level blurs the question the scale answers best: what repertoire can this choir take on? Presence would deserve, in my view, an axis of its own.

It’s a detail, and above all it’s a detail that shows the tool works: at last it gives us something to discuss.

Level isn’t status

There’s one thing this scale makes visible that has always struck me: a choir’s level and its status don’t match.

I’ve come across professional ensembles, people paid to sing, who were nowhere near the level described by the top rungs of the scale. No reliable sight-reading, intonation that came apart at the first exposed passage. And I’ve heard amateur choirs who, in their own repertoire, would have stood comparison with many paid groups.

Status tells you how an ensemble is organised. It tells you nothing about what it can do. A scale based on skills forces you to look at what is really happening in the room, not at the label on the door.

The book

Du choriste au chœur

A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.

Discover the book

What the scale changes for conductors

The first benefit is almost silly: at last we can talk to each other. Telling a colleague that their choir is a B1 leaning towards B2 in reading but still A2 in a cappella intonation conveys in one sentence what a quarter of an hour of explanation couldn’t get across.

The second is more interesting. A shared scale lets you put the question to the choir itself. Ask your singers where they would place themselves. The gaps will surprise you, between those who have been underestimating themselves for ten years and those who don’t realise what they’re missing. The discussion that follows is often worth more than a diagnosis handed down from above.

The third is that a level with a name becomes a level you can aim for. A choir that knows it’s A2 can decide together to work on reading to reach B1. It’s no longer a vague impression of progressing or standing still, it’s a heading.

What the scale changes for choir singers

For a choir singer, knowing where you stand isn’t a matter of ego. It’s a matter of pleasure.

Put in a choir well above your level, you spend your rehearsals surviving: you never look up, you enjoy nothing, you go home exhausted. Put in a choir well below it, you get politely bored and end up leaving without quite knowing why. In both cases it’s nobody’s fault, it’s a question of fit.

Being able to say, when you’re looking for an ensemble, ‘I’m more of a B1, I read a bit, I hold my line but I lose it when things get chromatic’, gives you a chance of landing in the right place first time.

What a scale doesn’t tell you yet

A scale describes a choir. It doesn’t tell you which piece to give it. Between knowing that your group is a B1 and choosing the June programme, there’s still a step to take, and that’s exactly the step the usual answers try to make.

That’s what the rest of the series is about. The next article, Why some scores are so hard to sing, tackles a stubborn misconception: we think a piece’s difficulty comes from the number of parts, and that’s almost always wrong.

In the meantime, go and look at Zana’s scale and try to place your choir on it. Then tell me in the comments where you put it and, above all, what made you hesitate.