I’ve often been told I’m unmanageable. Several choir directors have pointed it out to me over the years, with that mix of irritation and affection you keep for people you don’t quite know where to put. And yet none of them has ever wanted to see me leave.
Why? Because when the arm goes up, I’m there. Really there. Score learnt, eyes connected, breath ready. The joke from thirty seconds ago is forgotten. I’m completely in the music, with the conductor, not trailing behind.
This apparent contradiction, being both the one who makes people roll their eyes and the one they can count on, may be exactly what builds a real rapport with a choir director. Not the silent submission of the model singer. Not the sterile rebellion of the one who challenges everything either. Something subtler, more alive, more musical.
And if you have reached this stage of your choral journey, after several years of singing, you probably know that your relationship with the director makes all the difference between an ordinary choral experience and something truly nourishing.
The non-negotiable foundation
Before talking about rapport, we have to talk about reliability. Because without it, everything else falls apart.
A choir director juggles dozens of things at once: the balance between sections, intonation, tempo, expression, group dynamics, the clock ticking away, egos to handle with care, fragilities to support. The last thing they need is to wonder whether this singer knows their part or whether that one is going to miss their entry at bar 47 again.
Working on your score at home isn’t overzealousness. It’s the basics. It is what lets you arrive at rehearsal with enough distance to listen to the others, watch the director and feel where the music is going. If you are still sight-reading your notes while everyone else is polishing the dynamics, you are not in the same musical time and space. You are a step behind, and that gap can be felt.
I have come across technically excellent singers who would routinely turn up to rehearsal without having opened their score all week. They got by, of course, thanks to their ear and their experience. But they could never truly be in musical dialogue with the director, because they were too busy catching up. Their energy went into survival, not creation.
Being present matters too, physically and mentally. Present at rehearsals, of course, but present in the moment. Not checking your phone while the basses work on their passage. Not chatting with your neighbour during instructions. Not thinking about your shopping list while the director explains a dynamic.
That kind of presence can be felt. The director knows exactly who is with them and who is somewhere else. They can see it in people’s eyes, in their responsiveness, in that quality of attention that cannot be faked. And when they look for something to lean on in the choir, a pair of eyes to anchor themselves to, they instinctively turn to the ones who are really there.
And then there is that instant readiness when the work begins. The arm goes up, and you are ready. Not looking for the right page, not finishing your sentence, not clearing your throat. Ready. That instant responsiveness is a gift you give the director. It tells them: I’m here, I trust you, let’s go.
Reading intentions, not just gestures
Following a choir director isn’t obeying a series of signals the way you would follow traffic lights. It means entering a silent conversation where the gestures are only the visible part of a much richer exchange.
An experienced director communicates far beyond the beat. Their eyes prepare an entry before their hand even moves. The tension in their shoulders announces a crescendo. A slight smile can mean ‘good, keep it like that’ or ‘careful, here comes the tricky bit’. The way they breathe tells you how you should breathe. Their whole body speaks, and learning to read that language takes time.
At first, you focus on the right hand, the one beating time. That’s normal; it is the most obvious landmark. Then you start to see the left hand, the one that shapes the dynamics, that holds back or releases. And gradually you widen your field of vision to take in everything: the face, the posture, the overall energy coming from the director.
Du choriste au chœur
A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.
Discover the bookBut there is something subtler still. With experience, you begin to anticipate what the director is going to ask for before they ask. You feel that this passage calls for a shared breath at exactly this point. You sense that the phrase wants to stretch slightly before it resolves. You understand that the piano coming up is not just any piano, but a particular colour the director has been looking for over three rehearsals.
This anticipation isn’t disobedience. It is exactly the opposite. It is listening so deeply that it gets ahead of the request. You are not taking initiative against the director; you are thinking with them. You are inside their musical mind at the same time as your own.
And when a director feels that their singers are thinking the music with them, not after them, something changes in the way they conduct. They can go further, suggest subtler things, take interpretative risks, because they know they will be followed. Trust sets creativity free.
Social timing
Now let’s talk about what often makes the difference between a good singer and a singer nobody wants to lose: a sense of social timing.
A choir rehearsal is a shared space with its moments of tension and its moments of release. There is the time for intense work, when concentration is at its peak and the slightest stray noise feels like an assault. There is the time of the informal break, when bonds form and humour flows. And sometimes there is the time of frustration, when a passage just won’t come despite everyone’s efforts, when tiredness builds up, when nerves are frayed.
Knowing how to move between these moments is a skill in its own right. A skill that can’t really be taught, that you acquire through observation and experience.
Knowing when a little joke will lighten the atmosphere and give the group a lift. Knowing when, on the contrary, you need to keep quiet and let the director handle a delicate moment. Sensing when the mood needs lightening and when it needs protecting. Reading the group’s tiredness, the first signs of irritation, the discouragement creeping in.
The singers people call ‘unmanageable’ are often the ones who bring life to the group, who dare to be themselves, who aren’t content to be silent performers. They are the ones who make people laugh, who ease the tension, who make the rehearsal room more human. But the ones you want to keep are the ones who know how to judge it. Who understand that their energy is an asset when it serves the group, and a problem when it gets in the way.
It is a subtle balance. Too well-behaved, and you are invisible: you blend into the crowd without leaving a trace. Too present, and you are overbearing: you take up space that isn’t yours. The happy medium is the ability to be fully yourself while staying at the service of the music and the group. To exist without crushing. To contribute without imposing.
I have seen brilliant singers become disliked because they didn’t understand this timing. They always spoke up at the wrong moment, made comments when the director needed silence, joked when the group needed to concentrate. Their talent didn’t make up for their lack of social awareness.
The rapport that builds over time
There is one thing that can be neither forced nor rushed: time spent together.
When you sing with the same director for several years, a kind of mutual knowledge settles in, almost organically. You know how they react when things go wrong: do they get annoyed, do they withdraw, do they use humour to take the drama out of it? You recognise that little frown that means ‘tenors, you’re flat’. You anticipate their interpretative choices because you have understood their musical sensibility, their preferences, their pet obsessions.
You also know what brings them joy. That passage that comes off and draws a smile from them. That quality of sound they have been looking for for weeks and which finally appears. That togetherness in the group that shows in a perfectly held silence.
And they know you too. They know you tend to rush in the passages you love. They know your voice needs a little time to warm up in the morning. They know they can look at you to steady the section when it starts to waver, because you are reliable. They know your strengths and your weaknesses, and they take them into account.
This mutual knowledge creates an incredibly rich silent dialogue. A glance is enough where three sentences of explanation used to be needed. A slight hand signal replaces a long demonstration. The music flows more freely because communication has become intuitive, almost telepathic.
Du choriste au chœur
A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.
Discover the bookI have had moments in concert when I felt the conductor and I were thinking exactly the same thing at the same instant. That shared breath before a delicate entry, when I knew precisely when they were going to give the cue. That imperceptible slowing at the end of a phrase, which we began together without any discussion. That smile exchanged after a passage that came off, which said ‘we did it’ without a word.
Moments like these can’t be bought or ordered. They are built, rehearsal after rehearsal, concert after concert, year after year. They are the fruit of sustained mutual attention, of accumulated trust, of a shared history.
What it gives the director
We often talk about what the director gives the singers: direction, structure, musical vision, high standards, knowledge passed on. We talk less about what singers can give the director. And yet this relationship is not a one-way street.
A choir director, even an experienced one, needs feedback. Not flattery, not polite compliments, but the subtle feedback that is the musical response of their ensemble. When the singers are really with them, really connected, they can feel it in the sound that comes out. And that sound guides them as much as they produce it.
Conducting is not a monologue, it is a dialogue. The director suggests, the choir responds, and that response shapes the next suggestion. A crescendo that truly builds, that grows with conviction, encourages the director to go even further. A passage that stays flat despite their indications tells them they need to find another approach.
The singers with real rapport are also the ones who dare, tactfully and at the right moment, to pass on useful information. Pointing out that a tempo may be a little fast for the words to stay intelligible. Suggesting that a breath could be moved to make it more comfortable. Mentioning that a passage is causing vocal difficulties. This isn’t challenging the director’s authority, it is enriching their perception with information they can’t have from the podium.
I have seen directors grow through contact with their most committed singers. Not because those singers lectured them, but because they created a space for musical dialogue where the director could take risks, try things out and refine their interpretation in real time. A space of trust where mistakes were allowed and experiment was encouraged.
When the relationship between director and singer reaches this level of rapport, it is no longer vertical. It becomes a partnership in the service of the music. The director is still the director, of course. They are the one who decides, who settles things, who carries the overall vision. But they rely on singers who are no longer mere performers. Singers who think, who feel, who suggest, who carry the musical project with them.
Becoming that singer
If you are reading this article, you probably already have a few years of choral singing behind you. You are past the stage of learning the basics, finding your place in the section, wondering whether you sing in tune.
The question now is: what kind of singer do you want to become?
You can remain a good, reliable, discreet member who does the work without making waves. That is honourable, and many choirs need those silent pillars who hold the building up without seeking the limelight.
But you can also aim for something else. That rapport with your director that turns the choral experience into something deeper. That feeling of being a true partner in the music being made, not just an instrument playing it. That human and musical connection that gives singing together its full meaning.
It takes work, presence, social intelligence. It takes humility too: knowing that the director sees things you don’t, accepting their direction even when you would have done it differently, recognising that you are not always right. And it takes time, a lot of time spent together building that mutual trust, accumulating the shared experiences on which rapport is founded.
But when that rapport is there, when you feel you are truly part of something with your director and your fellow singers, choral singing takes on another dimension. It is no longer just singing together. It is thinking together, breathing together, creating together. It is that rare feeling of being exactly where you belong, connected to others, in the service of something bigger than yourself.
And that may be the finest reward you can find in a choir.
Corentin
Share your thoughts on this article