You know that strange feeling when your choir director asks for a pianissimo and you find yourself whispering, losing all vocal presence? Or when a forte is called for and you hear yourself shouting rather than singing? How many times have I heard: ‘To sing piano, sing less loudly!’ And yet that is one of the biggest misunderstandings in choral singing.
By the way, if this strikes a chord with you, don’t hesitate to click the little heart to let me know, and above all share your own experiences with dynamics in the comments…
Because, you see, dynamics have almost nothing to do with volume. Of course there is a correlation, but what comes first in dynamics is intensity, character, phrasing. Think of a stage actor whispering: he whispers, yet you can hear him at the back of the theatre. His vocal placement stays the same, and so does his projection. That is exactly what happens with a well-controlled pianissimo.
Approaching dynamics as an expressive language rather than a simple variation in decibels is going to take us on a fascinating journey through music history and the technical subtleties of choral singing.
How history shaped dynamics: when they took on meaning
To understand why we so often get dynamics wrong, we need to go back to their origins. Because the expressive palette we know today hasn’t always existed.
Mozart’s time: when forte already meant ‘give it everything’
In the Classical period, with Haydn and Mozart, composers used only six dynamic levels: from pianissimo to fortissimo¹. And this is where it gets interesting: in Mozart, when you see forte in the score, you are already at full power. There is no hidden reserve, no possible ‘even louder’.
This limitation wasn’t a lack of imagination; it reflected the instruments of the day. The arrival of the fortepiano (literally ‘loud-soft’) was revolutionary because it finally made it possible to alternate quickly between forte and piano². Before that, with the harpsichord, dynamics were achieved by other means: adding or removing parts, doubling the bass at the octave, or using rapid arpeggiation³.
But above all, forte and piano didn’t only mean volumes. Forte suggested something heavy, wide, broad, even angry or anxious. Piano suggested lightness, sweetness, pleading, melancholy⁴. Each dynamic carried an emotional world, not just an indication of sound.
The Romantic revolution: the invention of extremes
Then came the Romantic era, and everything changed. Beethoven was one of the first to introduce pianississimo (ppp) and fortississimo (fff)⁵. But it was Verdi who pushed the concept to the extreme: in his opera Otello, he uses as many as seven consecutive ps (ppppppp) to create a striking dramatic effect⁶.
This development wasn’t only artistic; it was technical too. Romantic pianos had metal frames instead of wooden ones and went from five to eight octaves, offering incomparable strength and range of sound⁷. Composers could at last explore the extreme dramatic contrasts that characterise the Romantic repertoire.
What this means for us today
This historical perspective changes everything about how we approach dynamics. When you sing Mozart, bear in mind that his forte already represents your maximum, and that his contrasts are measured and elegant. When you tackle Verdi, you can allow yourself those striking dramatic effects, those pianissimos that brush against silence.
Each era developed its own dynamic language. Knowing it is like learning several musical dialects. Your voice stays the same, but you adapt your expressive palette to the style of the piece.
Du choriste au chœur
A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.
Discover the bookThe teaching paradox: why pp is harder than ff
Here is a truth many choir singers are surprised to discover: it is harder to sing a good pianissimo than a good fortissimo. And that completely contradicts our first instinct.
The ‘let your voice go first’ approach
Most singing teachers start by saying: ‘Go on, let your voice go, sing out!’ That’s no accident. Developing a deep, full resonance first establishes the right technical foundations⁸. Once you have mastered that full resonance, you can learn to ‘take it away’ gradually while keeping the placement and the quality⁹.
It is exactly the opposite of what beginners do instinctively: they start by whispering, thinking it’s easier, then try to ‘force’ their way towards forte. This approach generally leads to tension and vocal difficulties.
Why pianissimo is so delicate
Pianissimo requires what in Italian is called fila della voce, the ‘thread of the voice’. This technique consists of passing a narrow, vertical, supported column of air through the vocal folds¹⁰. It is one of the hardest skills to acquire, because it needs as much diaphragmatic support as a forte, if not more, but with infinitely subtler control.
Imagine holding a taut silk thread in a storm. You can’t loosen your grip (that would mean losing support), but you mustn’t grip too hard either (that would tighten the voice). This image captures the complexity of pianissimo well: keeping the technical structure while lightening the expression.
Research in vocal physiology confirms this difficulty: ‘nothing is more apt to tie up a voice than the excessive singing of the pianissimo’¹¹. That is why this dynamic must be worked on gradually, with patience and method.
The technique of constant placement
Here is the secret that all experienced choir singers eventually discover: to sing a good pianissimo, you must keep your abdominal muscles engaged exactly as if you were singing forte, and only reduce the flow of air leaving your mouth¹².
In practice, that means:
- Keeping the same diaphragmatic support
- Keeping the same resonance placement
- Reducing only the amount of air you use
- Keeping the same expressive intention
It’s like adjusting a hot tap: you keep the same pressure in the pipes, but you just regulate how far it is open.
Dynamics ≠ volume: the art of intensity
Now let’s get to the heart of the matter: understanding what dynamics really are. Because if they aren’t volume, what defines them?
Intensity of intention
True dynamics are intensities of intention, emotional colours. When you sing a pianissimo, you are not murmuring: you are projecting a gentle intention with the same technical precision as a forte. Your vocal placement stays the same, and so does your resonance, but you change the colour of your expression.
Think of the difference between reading a love letter and announcing a train departure. Even if you read both at the same volume, the intention, the phrasing and the vocal colour will be completely different. That, precisely, is the art of dynamics.
The whisper that carries
Let’s go back to our stage actor. When he whispers on stage, his ‘whisper’ has nothing to do with the one you use so as not to wake someone up. He projects his whisper, he gives it density, a presence that lets the audience in the back row catch every word and every emotion.
Singing is the same. A professional pianissimo has that quality of a ‘projected whisper’: soft to the ear, but dense in intention and presence. It doesn’t disappear into the space; it inhabits it differently.
Practical exercises to develop this control
One particularly effective exercise is to sing a single note, moving gradually from soft to loud, then from loud to soft, without changing placement or colour¹³. It is extremely difficult at first, but it develops exactly the control you need.
You can also work on the ‘thread of the voice’ by holding a pianissimo note for as long as possible, making sure it keeps its density and beauty from start to finish. If it starts to bleat or loses its colour, you have lost the right balance between support and flexibility.
Du choriste au chœur
A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.
Discover the bookIn a choral setting: presence without domination
Now, how do we apply all this in a choir? Because singing in a group adds an extra dimension to handling dynamics.
The challenge of homogeneity
Acoustic research reveals an interesting phenomenon: in a mixed group of singers, a few loud voices naturally tend to dominate the fortissimo if everyone sings, while the pianissimo only works if all the voices that can’t really sing softly drop out¹⁴.
This raises a delicate question: should homogeneity be sacrificed to preserve individual quality? Or should some singers be asked to restrict their dynamic range to fit in with the group?
The answer lies in listening to one another and adapting intelligently. Each singer needs to develop the ability to measure out their intensity according to the context, without giving up their personal colour.
Strategies for collective balance
Here are a few practical approaches that work well:
For collective pianissimos: Rather than asking everyone to sing ‘less loudly’, encourage each person to sing with the same delicate intention, keeping their presence but refining their colour. The result will be a living pianissimo rather than a collective murmur.
For fortissimos: Remember that in some repertoire (such as Mozart), forte already represents the desirable maximum. No need to ‘overdo it’: focus on the nobility and generosity of the sound.
Listening as your guide: Develop your ability to hear the whole ensemble while you sing. Your dynamics should constantly adjust to what is happening around you, as in a musical conversation.
Keeping your personality within the whole
The most beautiful thing about all this is that understanding dynamics properly paradoxically lets you be more personal within the group. When you master the art of measuring out your intensity without losing your colour, you enrich the group’s palette instead of dissolving into it.
Two singers can sing the same pianissimo with the same technical accuracy, but with slightly different colours that complement each other. This diversity within unity is exactly what makes a mature choir so rich.
The art of musical conversation
In the end, dynamics are your way of speaking with your voice. The more you master them, the more subtleties, emotional shades and delicate intentions you can express.
It is a long-term apprenticeship that takes patience with yourself. Start by establishing your forte firmly, your full, generous resonance. Then gradually learn to ‘take away’ intensity without losing quality. Explore those colours of intention that turn the same note into a thousand different expressions.
And above all, don’t forget that dynamics aren’t rigid instructions to be applied blindly. They are the expression of your musical sensitivity, your personal way of carrying the music and sharing it with those who listen to you.
In that magnificent conversation that is polyphony, your dynamics are your signature, your unique contribution to the collective dialogue. So breathe, listen, dare, and let your voice find its colours in this constant musical exchange.
The art of dynamics is, in the end, the art of being fully yourself in the service of something bigger than yourself.
Corentin
Notes:
¹ Dynamics (music), Wikipedia. In the Romantic period, composers greatly expanded the vocabulary for describing dynamic changes in their scores. Where Haydn and Mozart specified six levels (pp to ff)…
² Donna Gunn, ‘Louder isn’t better, it’s just louder: what eighteenth-century performance practice teaches about dynamics’, OUPblog, 2017. The novelty of the fortepiano wasn’t the extreme range of volume as we know today, but its ability to quickly alternate and facilitate finesse.
³ Beethoven’s Dynamics in Keyboard Works, Music and Practice, 2021. On a harpsichord with one keyboard, passages marked piano may be produced by a moderate touch and by diminishing the number of parts…
⁴ Donna Gunn, op. cit. Consider forte to possibly portray heavy, wide, broad, angry, anxious, big, or strong; piano to portray light, sweet, pleading, sorrowful, or melancholy.
⁵ Dynamics (music), Wikipedia. Where Haydn and Mozart specified six levels (pp to ff), Beethoven used also ppp and fff…
⁶ Ibid. Giuseppe Verdi, in Scene 5 (Act II from his opera Otello), uses ppppppp (7 ps).
⁷ ‘Keys Full Of Passion: The Piano’s Role In The Romantic Period’, The London Piano Institute, 2024. Instead of constructing the piano frames out of wood, during the Romantic period, the frames were made of metal, improving the durability of the instrument.
⁸ ‘Secrets of Svengali, The Pianissimo’, Petersen Voice Studio, 2014. When I first began to teach you your slow scales, I told you to sing as deeply and loudly as possible…
⁹ Ibid. For the singer trained from the first by the method Trilby is getting, the pianissimo is an easy accomplishment.
¹⁰ ‘Vocal Technique: Putting it All Together’, Musical U, 2017. ‘Fila della voce’, which means ‘thread of the voice’ in Italian, is a beautiful pianissimo color that is very difficult to learn as it requires just as much (if not more) support from the diaphragm.
¹¹ ‘Secrets of Svengali, The Pianissimo’, op. cit. nothing is more apt to tie up a voice than the excessive singing of the pianissimo…
¹² ‘Volume control and singing Pianissimo’, Jameson Vocal Studio, 2021. try singing loudly and then diminish the air flow out of your mouth by literally blowing less air while keeping your abs completely engaged as if you are singing loudly.
¹³ ‘Vocal Technique: Putting it All Together’, op. cit. A helpful exercise to learn fila della voce and the art of pianissimo is to take the voice from soft to loud to soft again on a single pitch.
¹⁴ ‘Acoustic factors affecting the dynamic range of a choir’, PMC. For a non-homogeneous group of singers, a few loud voices dominate ff if everyone sings, while pp is not achieved effectively without suppressing all voices that cannot sing soft.
Share your thoughts on this article