You are in the middle of a concert. A few metres in front of you, the soprano from your choir launches into her solo. It’s a piece that has already moved you in rehearsal, but tonight, in this acoustic, in this light, something tips over. Her voice unfolds a phrase, and suddenly you feel a wave rising. Your throat tightens. Your eyes sting. And in a few seconds, it’s your own entry. You know exactly what you should do, you have rehearsed it twenty times. But part of you, at this precise moment, has no wish whatsoever to sing. It wants to cry.

This scene happens more often than you might think, and many choir singers go through it in silence, convinced they are too fragile, too sensitive, ill-equipped for the stage. I would like to offer you a completely different way of looking at it. Your sensitivity is not a flaw. It is very probably what led you to choral singing in the first place. But it needs looking after, because at the precise moment when real emotion overwhelms you, it becomes your voice’s physiological enemy. And it is worth understanding exactly what is happening, and what you can do in the seconds that follow.

What really happens in the body when emotion rises

Before looking for the solution, we need to look the mechanism in the face. When you feel like crying, your body sets off a cascade of very precise reflexes, and every one of them is bad news for your instrument.

You know the first sign already. It’s the famous lump in the throat. That isn’t a metaphor, it’s an anatomical fact. The muscles around the larynx contract, the pharynx narrows, and the resonating space your voice was meant to pass through suddenly shrinks. At the same moment, the larynx itself rises. For a choir singer, this is a silent disaster. All your technical work, perhaps for years, has been about letting that larynx settle, giving it room, opening up that space. A larynx that rises under the pull of a sob means a voice that gets stuck, loses its roundness and turns pinched.

Lower down, the diaphragm starts having irregular spasms. Those jolts are the beginning of sobbing. Your support, that steady column of air you have patiently tamed, becomes unstable and choppy. You can no longer spin out a phrase. Your nose starts running, which closes off the upper resonators. Your eyes blur, which cuts you off from the score and the conductor. The whole system locks up in a few seconds.

This is the mechanism you need to have understood once and for all. Real emotion doesn’t weaken your voice for mysterious reasons. It weakens it because the physiological reflexes of crying are, point by point, the opposite of the conditions singing needs. If you let those reflexes take hold, you won’t produce beautiful, moving singing. You’ll produce broken singing.

The actor’s old paradox

The idea that real emotion can harm a performance is nothing new. In the eighteenth century, Denis Diderot wrote a famous text, the Paradoxe sur le comédien (the Paradox of the Actor), which left its mark on all thinking about theatre. His thesis seemed scandalous at the time, and it still surprises people today. The greatest actors, Diderot said, are not those who really cry on stage. They are those who have observed crying in others and in themselves, dissected its signs, and can reproduce them at will with perfect precision, without being overwhelmed themselves.

For Diderot, the actor who lets himself be swept away by emotion becomes uneven. One night he will be dazzling, another night absent, because he depends on his inner state. The actor who masters the signs, on the other hand, is reliable. He can give the audience the same emotion night after night, because what he is playing are the outward marks of the feeling, not the feeling itself. That doesn’t make him cold. He is filled with a particular warmth, that of the precise observer who knows exactly where to place the colours.

In singing, this paradox is even truer than in the theatre, for the physiological reason we have just seen. An actor who really cries can still speak through the tears, and some even use it as an effect. A choir singer who really cries can no longer sing, full stop. Their larynx is closed. Their column of air is broken. That doesn’t mean you should sing without feeling anything: it would be hollow and everyone would hear it. It means you have to learn to feel in a different way.

The choir singer’s double awareness

Here is the image that, I believe, changes the most for singers once they make it their own. On stage, you are not one person. You are two at once, and these two beings live side by side the whole time.

The first I call the Heart. It’s the warm part. It is completely invested in the story the piece tells, in the images of the text, in the beauty of the harmony. It is the part that is moved, that gives, that resonates. It is what makes your interpretation alive, what touches the audience, what ultimately justifies your being there rather than in front of the television.

The second I call the Pilot. It’s the cool part. It stands back, slightly above, as if in a control tower. It keeps an eye on the technique while the Heart looks after the soul. It checks that the last note was in tune, that the next breath is in the right place, that the jaw isn’t clenching, that your eyes are on the conductor. It doesn’t switch off the emotion. It simply makes sure you don’t become your own obstacle.

The mistake is to believe you have to choose between the two. The singer who relies only on the Heart is moving two nights running and disastrous on the third, because they depend entirely on their emotional state. The singer who relies only on the Pilot is accurate but icy, and the audience leaves saying something was missing without being able to name it. The great performer brings both to life at once. They give the audience the illusion of total abandon, while inside they keep absolute control of the vehicle.

This double awareness isn’t acquired in a day. It is built concert after concert. But it starts with a very simple decision, made in rehearsal, long before the stage: accepting the idea that it is possible to be deeply moved and technically precise in the same instant. As long as you secretly set those two dimensions against each other, you swing between them. Once you understand that they work together, you reach another kind of freedom.

Three anchors in the body when the wave comes

All very well in theory, you may say. But on stage, in the middle of a piece, when the wave is already rising, what do you actually do? You have three or four seconds to react before your throat closes. Here, in this order, is what works.

The first gesture happens in the chin. You lower it very slightly: half a centimetre is enough. It is completely invisible to the audience. It seems counter-intuitive, because singing posture usually asks for a chin parallel to the floor. But remember what the sob does. It makes the larynx rise. Lowering the chin a little creates a mechanical counter-movement that helps the larynx come back down. It is a tiny gesture that instantly releases the closing of the pharynx. Many opera singers use this micro-adjustment without even thinking about it, because they have learnt it in their bodies.

The second gesture happens in the breath. Take a slow breath in through your nose, imagining the air is a little cool, as if it were coming through a window open to the outside. This slow, deep nasal breath sends a very precise signal to the nervous system. It activates the parasympathetic branch, the one that brakes, calms and slows the heart rate. The sobbing reflex depends on the sympathetic branch, the one that speeds up and runs away with itself. In one conscious breath, you quite literally change your nervous gear. It is the most powerful tool in your kit, and also the least visible. No one around you will ever know what you have just done.

The third gesture happens in the feet. Curl your toes inside your shoes. Gently, but firmly. It sounds absurd, but this tiny muscular effort has two remarkable effects. It brings you sharply back down into the floor, into the lower body, where emotion can’t carry you away. And it takes up a small corner of your attention, just enough to divert the system from the emotional spiral it was starting to go down. You are still present in the music, but you have dropped an anchor in physical reality.

Together, these three gestures take less than five seconds. They follow on from one another almost automatically once you have practised them two or three times. And their strength lies precisely in the fact that they work through the body. When emotion overwhelms you, you can no longer reason properly: it is not the moment for inner pep talks. You need a physical action, simple and discreet, that requires no negotiation with yourself.

The emergency stop button: unplugging the meaning

If, despite these anchors, the wave keeps rising, you have one last tool, a more radical one. It is what I call unplugging the meaning.

For thirty seconds, you stop listening to your colleague with the Heart. You stop thinking about the text, the story, the beauty of what is happening altogether. You switch back into pure technician mode. Your next note is an E. Your next breath comes before the next bar. The conductor has just signalled piano. That is all that exists for those thirty seconds.

Putting it like that may sound a little cynical. It isn’t cynicism at all. It is a safety measure. You aren’t cutting yourself off from the music for good, you are temporarily putting the Heart on standby so that the Pilot can take back the controls. Once you are through the danger zone, two phrases later, you can gradually plug back in. You will find the meaning again, you will let the emotion back in, but this time your voice will be available to carry it.

This unplugging mechanism is probably the most important one to understand, because it takes the drama out of everything else. It tells you that at any moment, you can choose, through a precise mental act, to turn your sensitivity down for a few seconds to save the passage. You are never trapped. There is always a way out.

What we work on is not feeling less

I would now like to come to what seems to me the heart of the matter, because many of the singers I meet are fighting the wrong battle. They believe that by hardening themselves, armouring themselves, learning to be less affected, they will become better performers. The exact opposite is true.

A voice that feels nothing can be heard straight away. It is in tune, it is in time, and it is hollow. The audience might not be able to say why, but they would leave the concert with that slight unease you feel in front of a beautiful performance without a soul. If you smother your sensitivity to protect yourself from overflowing, you buy your peace of mind at the cost of your colour.

So what we work on isn’t feeling less. It is keeping one foot on the ground while the other dances. It is letting the Heart do its job, which is to be moved, while the Pilot does its own, which is to stay at the helm. It is coexistence, not combat, and certainly not amputation.

With a little practice, you reach a surprising place. You can listen to your colleague’s heartbreaking solo, truly take it in, be deeply moved by it, and at the same instant remain technically ready for your own entry. You are no less sensitive than before. You are more stable. Your sensitivity hasn’t diminished: the instrument has grown to carry it.

Sensitivity as raw material

If you are the kind of person who is easily moved while singing, keep this firmly in mind. That disposition is one of the most precious a choir singer can have. It is the raw material of every true interpretation. Without it, you might sing the notes well, but you couldn’t tell the story of the music.

The work I am suggesting in this article isn’t work against your sensitivity, it is work in its service. You give it a framework that lets it live fully without breaking everything on the way. You teach it the house rules of the voice. And once those rules are second nature, you will discover that you can go much further emotionally than before, because you are no longer afraid of losing control.

This question, in all its forms, runs through chapter 8 of the book I wrote last year, Du choriste au choeur (in French; the English edition, ‘From Singer to Choir’, is coming in 2027). In it I go into detail about double awareness, Diderot’s paradox, and the way the text and the sound itself become vehicles for an emotion that is shared rather than private. If this subject spoke to you, you will find there plenty to take the thinking further and new tools to try in rehearsal.

For tonight, just remember this. The next time the wave rises during a concert, don’t fight it from the inside. Lower your chin by half a centimetre, breathe in slowly through your nose imagining slightly cool air, curl your toes in your shoes. And if necessary, unplug the meaning for thirty seconds. Your Heart will wait. It will come back, intact, as soon as the Pilot has got through the difficult stretch. That, in the end, is what becoming a performer means: learning to protect your sensitivity instead of being at its mercy.

Safe travels, and have a wonderful singing season.