A choral score is difficult when its lines are hard to sing one by one, not when it has a lot of parts. Voice leading, in other words the path each part takes to get from one chord to the next, weighs far more than the number of voices. A four-part piece with poor voice leading can resist for months; an eight-part piece with good voice leading can come together in three rehearsals.
This is the second article in the series on finding the right level for a choir. The first, ‘Can you measure a choir’s level?’, offered a vocabulary for describing a choir. Here is the other half of the problem: describing a score.
The number-of-parts reflex
When you’re looking for a piece, the first filter is almost always the same. How many parts? Four, fine. Six, we’ll see. Eight, too hard. Then you check the range, making sure the sopranos don’t go too high and the basses don’t go too low, and you tell yourself the rest will come with work.
Then the piece reaches rehearsal, and it resists where you least expected. A four-part piece that looked well behaved falls apart on the same bar every time. An eight-part piece you were dreading almost sings itself. To understand why, I’ll start from a piece I love dearly and that has taught me an enormous amount, precisely because it’s harder than it looks.
Poulenc and pianistic writing
The first of Francis Poulenc’s Quatre motets pour le temps de Noël, O magnum mysterium, is a marvel. Sumptuous harmonic colours, a suspended atmosphere, that blend of fervour and gentleness you recognise in him straight away. On paper: four parts, a reasonable length, nothing extravagant in the ranges. A good amateur choir ought to be able to sing it.
And yet you hit a wall.
I call that wall pianistic writing. Poulenc thinks this music the way a pianist thinks a chord: vertically. Each chord is magnificent in itself, settled, colourful, perfectly spaced. But it’s conceived as an object under the fingers, not as the meeting point of four lines each moving on its own way. Voice leading takes second place.
At the keyboard, no problem. The hand moves, the next chord arrives, the pianist never has to sing the inner line. For a singer it’s another story. The tenor has to get from one note to the next with their voice, with no keyboard, in the middle of three other lines that are leaping about too. And when that path goes through a leap of a tritone, that unstable interval the ear finds so hard to place, it’s a recipe for disaster. For amateurs, obviously. But for professionals too, as soon as you demand that it be truly in tune.
This isn’t a criticism of Poulenc, a towering composer, whose piece is very well written. It’s simply very well written for an instrument that isn’t the voice.
Whitacre and easy-to-sing clusters
At the other extreme there’s a composer whose writing never fails to impress me: Eric Whitacre. On paper his scores are frightening. Endless clusters, chords of eight, ten, twelve notes packed tightly together, divisi in every section. With the number-of-parts filter, you would close the score straight away.
Yet his pieces are sung everywhere, by choirs of every level. Because the voice leading is remarkably intelligent. Very often, to get those insanely dense chords, each singer has only one thing to do: hold their note. The chord is built note by note, one voice comes in, then another beside it, then another, and the cluster forms by addition, without anyone ever having had to sing anything complicated.
That’s the whole difference. In Whitacre, the chord is the result of simple lines. In pianistic writing, the lines are the result of the chord, and they inherit all its complexity.
I try hard to draw on this when I write for voices. The rule I take from it is simple to state and hard to keep: however rich the whole, each line, taken on its own, must stay easy to sing.
Bach had already settled the question
There’s nothing modern about the idea. Open Johann Sebastian Bach’s harmonised chorales and look for what the textbooks call errors, those consecutive fifths or octaves every harmony student learns to avoid. You’ll find some. Not many, but you’ll find some.
My reading of these departures is this. In those places, avoiding the error would have meant complicating a line: one more leap, a detour, a note less natural to sing. And Bach clearly preferred to let the error through rather than spoil the line. For him, as for many others, voice leading is king. The textbook rule serves the music; it doesn’t command it.
Du choriste au chœur
A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.
Discover the bookHow do you assess the difficulty of a choral score?
In practice, this shift changes the way you read a score. Instead of counting the parts, you follow the lines. Five checks are enough to get an accurate idea.
The first is the simplest and the most revealing: sing each part on its own, without piano, without the others. Not sight-reading, but calmly, the way an average singer in your group would at home. A line that’s pleasant to sing alone, that makes melodic sense and whose intervals follow on naturally, will hold up within the whole. A line that jumps from note to note with no apparent logic will only hold up if the singer can cling to something else. And a cappella, there’s nothing else.
The second is to spot the unstable intervals and their context. A tritone, a seventh or an augmented second doesn’t pose the same problem in the middle of a phrase that prepares it as it does on an isolated entry. The same interval can be harmless or fearsome depending on what surrounds it.
The third looks at who sings alone. A passage where one section is exposed costs much more than a dense tutti. A choir can easily hide behind numbers, much less easily behind everyone else’s silence.
The fourth concerns rhythmic independence. Four parts moving in the same rhythm are a single difficulty. Four parts that stagger, imitate and answer one another are four difficulties, plus the difficulty of putting them together.
Finally, the fifth asks what’s holding things up. A piano or an organ is a handrail tuning can lean on. Take it away and the same piece suddenly changes level. It’s no accident that so many choirs sound good in an accompanied concert and struggle with the a cappella piece in the middle of the programme.
Difficulties you can’t see on the page
Some difficulties don’t appear on the score at all.
Language, first of all. A text in a language nobody speaks takes up an enormous share of attention, and that attention is taken away from listening. A simple piece in Latin can become a medium-level piece in Czech.
Length, next. With the same writing, two minutes and eight minutes don’t demand the same thing. Stamina, sustained concentration, tuning that has to hold until the very last note: it all adds up.
And finally slow tempo, which is always underestimated. People think slowness makes things easier. In reality, a slow a cappella piece leaves the choir nowhere to hide: every note lasts, every lapse in tuning can be heard, every breath has to be placed. Slow, soft pieces are often the most demanding in a programme.
What this changes for conductors and for singers
For whoever conducts, the consequence is direct: a piece can be in four parts and out of reach, or in eight parts and perfectly accessible. And when you’re set on a piece that’s badly written for the voice, because it’s beautiful and you’re right to love it, it’s better to know in advance and plan for the time it will take.
For singers, it’s a relief. If a piece that looks simple is resisting you, it isn’t necessarily you: it may have been conceived for ten fingers rather than for a voice. And if an impressive piece comes together easily, it isn’t a miracle, it’s the sign of writing that respects the person singing it.
Knowing how to read the difficulty of a piece doesn’t yet tell you which one to choose. That’s the question for the next article: how to build a programme that helps the choir grow without making it lose the desire to come back.
In the meantime, tell me in the comments which piece surprised you most: the one that looked simple and wasn’t, or the one that seemed frightening and turned out to be gentle to sing.
Share your thoughts on this article