A web page, a photo of a smiling group in front of an abbey, a tempting programme, a fee that’s no small sum, and a booking deadline ten days away. You’ve been hesitating for three weeks.

You have read the description over and over, which promises in-depth work in an exceptional setting, and you are exactly where you started: you have no idea what you will actually experience there.

That’s the problem with every singing course. The description pages all look alike, they all say the same thing, and they never answer the questions that really decide whether the week will be an unforgettable memory or five days of polite frustration.

Nobody asks these questions, because we’re afraid of coming across as the resident pain in the neck. That’s a shame, because serious organisers are happy to answer them, and the way they answer often tells you more than the whole brochure.

How long will you sing each day

It sounds silly, and yet it’s the first thing to check. A six-day course can mean five hours of singing a day, or two and a half hours split in two, with the rest taken up by side activities, free time and long, lingering meals.

Neither formula is better than the other. They simply aren’t aimed at the same people. Five hours a day is a real vocal workout, and it also carries a risk of fatigue if you haven’t sung since June.

Two and a half hours is comfortable, but don’t expect to transform your technique. The only real problem is discovering on arrival that you paid for one while thinking you were buying the other.

Ask for the timetable of a typical day. Not the programme for the week: the timetable for an ordinary Tuesday, hour by hour. If there isn’t one, that tells you something in itself.

The book

Du choriste au chœur

A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.

Discover the book

How many of you will be singing

This is the question that changes everything, and it’s the one least often stated. A course with eighteen people is an experience where the person leading can hear every voice, where your habits are spotted and worked on, where you have no choice but to own your line.

A course with eighty is something else: an impressive mass of sound, a real collective emotion, and a near certainty that nobody will look after you individually.

Here again, neither is bad. There is a particular joy in singing in a very large group, and it shouldn’t be looked down on.

But if you are going with the idea of sorting out a specific vocal problem (a top note that gets stuck, a breath that runs short, shaky intonation), a group of eighty won’t solve it. You’ll come home happy and exactly where you were.

Who is leading it, and have you ever heard their work

We often sign up for a course because of a place, a repertoire, dates that suit us. That’s a poor criterion. What makes a week good is the person leading it: the way they talk about a voice, their ability to correct without humiliating, their ear.

Look up what else they do. Listen to a recording of their regular ensemble. Watch a video, even a bad one, of them at work. You’ll learn more from six minutes of footage than from three pages of biography. And if you find nothing at all, no trace, no sound, ask yourself why.

Is the repertoire within your reach, and does it matter

Courses often advertise an ambitious programme, because that’s what draws people in. Eight-part motets, Renaissance polyphony, pieces from the 20th and 21st centuries.

The real question isn’t whether you are capable of it, but whether the course is designed so that you will be capable of it by the end.

A good course owns the gap. It sends out the scores in advance, sometimes learning tracks for each section, and it says so clearly: here is what you need to have worked on before you arrive.

A course that sends you nothing before day one, with a heavy programme, is a course where you will spend the week sight-reading. You won’t be making music, you’ll be doing group theory class, and you’ll come home exhausted without knowing why.

Is there a concert, and at what cost

Many courses end with a public performance. That’s an excellent thing: it gives the work a direction and an intensity. But find out what it involves in the last few days.

Sometimes the concert swallows up the end of the course: an endless dress rehearsal, staging, run-throughs, and the vocal work you came for disappears in favour of logistics.

If you are going in order to progress, a course without a concert can be a far better choice than one with. It isn’t intuitive, and yet it’s often true.

The real criterion, the one nobody talks about

Everything I’ve just written is useful, but it’s secondary to one single thing: why are you going?

If you are going to progress technically, you are looking for a small group, lots of hours, a leader whose work you have heard and, if possible, time singing on your own or in a small group.

If you are going to live a week out of time with music from morning till night, the setting, the atmosphere and the repertoire matter more than the teaching, and you can forget half of my questions. If you are going because you miss your choir and two months is a long time, then frankly almost any course will do, and you’ll come home happy.

The only possible failure is going for one of these reasons while signing up for a course designed for another. And that is decided entirely before you pay.

Have you already been on a course this summer, or are you still hesitating? Tell me in the comments what made you choose, or what is holding you back.