You sit down at the piano, score in hand. A few chords to warm up your fingers, then you start scribbling notes on manuscript paper. Perhaps you are trying to adapt for your ensemble that song that has been going round your head for weeks? Or perhaps you are trying to create something new, a melody that feels like you?

Composing or arranging for your choir is fascinating territory, but full of pitfalls. A place where your creativity meets vocal constraints, where your artistic ambitions run into the reality of your singers’ ranges. And believe me, I made a few youthful mistakes that still make me smile today.

Understanding the difference means knowing where you’re going

Before you dive in, it is crucial to know which adventure you are signing up for. Composing means creating an original work from scratch: melody, harmony, structure, everything comes out of your imagination. Arranging means taking existing music and reinventing it for your vocal group.

Both approaches call for similar skills, but the stakes are different. When you compose, you have complete freedom, but also full responsibility for creating something coherent and singable. When you arrange, you have to respect the spirit of the original while adapting it to the particular features of your ensemble.

Personally, I started with arranging. It is often more accessible: you start from a solid base, a melody that already works, and you develop it for four voices. Jake Runestad, whom I greatly admire, actually cut his teeth arranging popular songs before moving on to his own original compositions.

Range: your first constraint… and your guide

Now let’s talk about what makes or breaks an arrangement: your singers’ tessitura. You know that feeling when a soprano strains on an E₅ for a whole passage? Or when your basses struggle to get below F₂? That is exactly what you need to avoid.

Tessitura is the zone in which each voice can move naturally, without excessive effort. For a soprano it is generally between C₄ and A₅, for an alto between G₃ and E₅, for a tenor between C₃ and G₄, and for a bass between F₂ and D₄. But careful: these figures are theoretical. Every singer has their own comfort zone, and that is what should guide your writing.

When I compose for AEVUM, I always think of the voices I know. The soprano who blossoms at the top but tightens below F₄, the tenor who is generous in the middle but cautious above F₄… These concrete considerations feed my writing far more than theoretical rules.

The book

Du choriste au chœur

A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.

Discover the book

Harmony: the art of making chords sing

Now that you have pinned down the ranges, you need to think about harmony. In a mixed choir you generally work in four parts: soprano, alto, tenor, bass. Each voice needs its own melodic logic while contributing to the overall harmony.

The classic mistake? Making all the voices move in parallel, like puppets tied to the same string. It is monotonous and goes against the nature of polyphony. Each vocal line needs its own breath, its moments in the foreground and in the background.

Take a C major chord: C-E-G-C. You can share it out between your four voices in a thousand ways. Soprano and tenor on C (an octave apart), alto on E, bass on G. Or soprano on G, alto and tenor on E, bass on low C. Each choice gives a different colour, a particular density.

The art of choral writing is also knowing when a voice can rest and when it can shine. In some passages, give your basses a breather while the upper voices weave a two-part melody. In others, give the men the spotlight while the women provide discreet support.

Pitfalls to avoid (and how I fell into them)

Ah, youthful mistakes… I wrote my first arrangements thinking that the more complex, the better. The result: scores that looked magnificent on paper but were impossible for amateurs to sing. The singers wore themselves out on awkward intervals, and the entries overlapped incomprehensibly.

First lesson, learnt the hard way: always test your writing with real voices. What seems simple at the piano can turn out to be treacherous for the voice. That perfect fifth between alto and tenor, so obvious on your keyboard, requires constant adjustment from the singers. That elegant semitone modulation can throw your singers if they don’t have solid harmonic landmarks.

Second pitfall: neglecting breathing. On paper, your phrases can stretch over twelve bars. In reality, your singers need to breathe, and not all at the same moment. Build in musical commas, places where each section can take a breath without breaking the overall line.

Third trap: uniform texture. If you write in four full parts all the time, the ear gets saturated. Vary the density: sometimes just two voices, sometimes five or six if you divide your sections, sometimes powerful unisons that give strength to your musical statement.

The question of the text: more than just a melody

When you work with a text, it becomes your guide. The natural stresses of the words must fit your melodic line. A stressed syllable naturally calls for a strong beat, a higher or longer note.

But there is something subtler: collective articulation. When your four sections sing different syllables at the same moment, intelligibility can suffer. Sometimes that is intentional: you are after an effect of texture, of sonic material. Sometimes it is a clumsiness that blurs the message.

In my arrangements, I make sure the consonants are articulated together at key moments. When the whole choir launches into an ‘Our Father’ or an ‘Alleluia’, that phonetic unanimity strengthens the emotional impact. In more contemplative passages, on the other hand, I can play with subtle offsets that create depth.

The book

Du choriste au chœur

A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.

Discover the book

Adapting to your ensemble’s level

Knowing your choir means knowing how far you can go without putting anyone in difficulty. An experienced ensemble can handle complex harmonies, canonic entries, bold modulations. A beginners’ group will need more transparent arrangements, with clear landmarks and reassuring intervals.

Adapting doesn’t mean dumbing down. You can create beauty with simple means. Some of my best-loved pieces use basic harmonies, but with particular attention to phrasing, dynamics and dramatic construction. Controlled simplicity is better than haphazard complexity.

The pleasure of creating for your own people

Despite all these pitfalls, composing or arranging for your ensemble remains an immense pleasure. There is something magical about hearing your creation performed by real voices for the first time, watching your singers’ faces as they discover their parts, feeling the work come to life before your ears.

It is also a wonderful teaching tool. By creating for your choir, you understand each section’s challenges from the inside. That experience feeds your conducting, your listening and your ability to support each singer’s progress.

And then there is the collective pride: ‘We made this.’ That sense of ownership strengthens the group’s cohesion and gives it a feeling of being unique. Your arrangement becomes a signature, something that belongs only to you.

So go for it. Start small, test a lot, listen to your singers. Their feedback is worth all the harmony textbooks in the world. And remember: in choral music, technique serves emotion, never the other way round. Your first success will be the one that touches the hearts of those who sing it.

Corentin