The first chord of the season. Twenty people who haven’t sung together for three months, an easy piece chosen on purpose so that things go well, and a sound that comes out hesitant, flat, low. We look at one another.

Somebody laughs nervously. The person conducting says something kind, we start again, and it’s barely better. At the break, you always hear the same phrases: we’re rusty, it’ll come back, we’ve lost it.

No. You haven’t lost anything. Something else is going on, and once you understand what, the first rehearsal in September stops being a slightly sad moment and becomes the most interesting one of the year.

Nobody has gone backwards, and yet it sounds worse

Take each singer individually. None of them has lost their voice: as we’ve seen, two months of silence don’t damage the vocal folds. Individually, everyone sings more or less as they did in June.

And yet the whole sounds noticeably worse. This apparent contradiction holds the whole truth about what a choir is.

What was lost over the summer isn’t in any of the twenty people. It’s what lies between them. A choir at the end of the season isn’t twenty individuals who sing well: it’s a network of invisible adjustments.

You know that the soprano on your left always comes in a hair early, and you anticipate it without thinking. You know that in that particular passage your section tends to go flat, and you hold it up.

You breathe at the same moment as your neighbour because you know their shoulder. None of this is written in the score and none of it is in the voices. It’s collective knowledge, spread across twenty bodies, and it evaporates as soon as you stop practising it.

That’s why the first rehearsal sounds worse: the choir, as a thing in itself, no longer exists. It has to be rebuilt.

The book

Du choriste au chœur

A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.

Discover the book

What the disappointment says about you

There’s a second phenomenon, a more private one, that nobody ever talks about.

In June, your choir sounded good. That’s the sound you kept in your head all summer, and it has had three months to quietly grow more beautiful in your memory.

Memory doesn’t keep the average rehearsals; it keeps the concert. So you come back in September with not your choir in your ear, but the best moment of your choir, idealised.

And you set that glorified memory against the first chord of the new season. The gap is huge, inevitably. But half of that gap doesn’t exist in the room; it exists in your head. It’s a disappointment of memory, not a disappointment of standard.

What comes back, and how fast

The good news is that this collective knowledge rebuilds itself much faster than it was built in the first place. It hasn’t been destroyed; it’s dormant.

In practice, allow three rehearsals for the listening to come back, that is, for you to start hearing the section opposite again instead of hearing only yourself.

Two or three more for stamina, the ability to last two hours without your breath getting shorter. And about a month for the choir’s collective intonation to get back to its June level, because it depends entirely on the first two.

In other words, by the end of October you’ll be exactly where you were in June. That isn’t an optimistic opinion; it’s what happens every year in every choir.

The one thing to do differently

Since what’s missing is listening and not voice, the first rehearsal shouldn’t be spent working on notes. It should be spent relearning how to be together.

Which means, very concretely: singing things you already know, not the new piece on the December programme. Singing in a circle rather than in rows, even if only for a quarter of an hour, because a circle forces you to hear everyone and see their faces.

Singing in unison, for a long time, which seems beneath a choir that sings in eight parts and is in fact the most demanding exercise there is. And talking, too. A twenty-minute break in September isn’t wasted time; it’s work.

If you’re a singer and not the one conducting, there’s still one thing you can do: look up. From the very first chord. It’s the reflex that will have suffered most over the summer, and it’s the one that rebuilds everything else.

The best moment of the year

I’ll end with what I really think. The first rehearsal in September is the most honest of the season’s fifty.

It’s the only evening when the choir is bare, with no automatic reflexes, no shared memories to hide anything. You hear exactly what twenty people produce when they have nothing but their attention.

And every year it’s also the same small miracle: people who are under no obligation to come, who have had the whole summer to lose interest, and who are nevertheless there, at 8 pm, with their scores.

The sound is ugly. Everyone is happy. That should be enough to tell you what this is really about.

How did your first rehearsal go this year? Tell me in the comments: I’m curious to know whether it’s the same everywhere.