A few days ago, a fellow choir director was telling me how hard she was finding it to put together a programme for the Fête de la Musique. ‘You see, if I do Mozart, people will say it’s always the same old thing. If I programme contemporary music, half my singers will pull a face and the audience will run for the door.’ Caught between a rock and a hard place, like so many others.

That conversation annoyed me, because it reveals a false dilemma that has been poisoning the music world for years. On one side, the eternal hits you hear every year under the Eiffel Tower: the Flower Duet from Lakmé, Mozart’s Requiem, Schubert’s Ave Maria. It’s beautiful, of course, but for heaven’s sake, there’s more to music than that. And above all, plenty of people find it bored-to-tears dull. On the other side, to look modern, we swing to the opposite extreme: atonal music going off in every direction, where nobody can find their way, sometimes not even the singers.

And yet between the two lies a whole continent that we systematically ignore. Contemporary composers who write tonal, accessible, emotionally direct music. The Jake Runestads, the Ola Gjeilos, the Karl Jenkinses (even if not everything he does is wonderful). Musicians who have understood that you can be modern without being impenetrable, that you can move people without watering things down.

Do you know Gjeilo’s Northern Lights, for example? It’s just beautiful. It’s music of today, written by a living composer, in a harmonic language that speaks to you straight away. Nothing revolutionary, no intellectual somersaults, just a beauty that grabs you by the gut. And yet how many programmers dare to step out of their comfort zone? How many prefer to play it safe with Fauré for the umpteenth time?

I come across this timidity everywhere. In the choral world, I sometimes hear remarks that leave me baffled. ‘Oh, you’re doing Jenkins? Don’t you find it a bit… easy?’ Easy for whom? For the singers who discover polyphony thanks to Exsultate? For the audience who are thrilled by a repertoire they can understand on first hearing?

As it happens, I’ve never sung Jenkins’s Dies Irae, and I’ve never heard it live. But I listen to it on a loop, and it feels like listening to music in a nightclub. It gives me goosebumps all over. So what? Why is it a problem if classical music can have the same effect on us as a techno track? Why is it demeaning for it to grab us by the gut so directly?

This unspoken hierarchy between ‘noble’ music and ‘popular’ music wears me out. As if complexity were necessarily a guarantee of quality. As if moving people directly were suspect. The other day, a colleague pointed out to me that my programmes sometimes lacked ‘depth’. I nearly answered that depth doesn’t necessarily lie in harmonic complexity. That it can also lie in that raw emotion that sweeps through a hall when forty voices come together on a melody that speaks to everyone.

Because that’s what this is about, deep down. Speaking to people. Not impressing them, not proving to them that we’re cultured. No: speaking to them. And for that, there’s no need to choose between dusty heritage and incomprehensible avant-garde.

Take my husband, for example. He doesn’t listen to classical music day to day. But when he comes to my concerts, he always finds them wonderful. Not out of marital politeness. Really. Because what he hears speaks to him directly. He doesn’t need anyone to explain the harmonic subtleties or the composer’s life story. The music does its work on its own.

The book

Du choriste au chœur

A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.

Discover the book

That’s exactly what Nicolas Kern did with the Parisiens Harmonistes. Every programme was designed to please people who knew nothing about music as much as the specialists. A constant back and forth. There might be some pieces that were a bit more intellectual, admittedly, but we tried not to give the audience too much information. Not out of condescension, quite the opposite. Out of kindness. So that people were glad they came, and didn’t leave thinking ‘oh dear, I didn’t understand a thing’.

This approach works. When I sang Jenkins’s The Armed Man at the Église de la Trinité in the 9th arrondissement, it was the first time I’d ever seen a standing ovation in a church. All right, musically it may not be the most mind-blowing experience, but it’s still impressive. People were on their feet, applauding, moved. Really moved. Not out of politeness.

And then there were all those experiences with Corinne, when I sang under her direction. The way she conducts this kind of contemporary repertoire is absolutely incredible. You could cry every time; in concerts we hold back the tears, so carried away are we by the moment. I know some people find that ridiculous, but never mind. That’s how I see things, and that’s what I want to stand for.

That reminds me of a 1982 interview with Ligeti that I listened to in the Radio France archives. He was grumbling because, after his concerts, people would come up to him saying ‘Oh yes, it was wonderful!’ And he was disgusted, because at the time he was writing music for horror films, in other words music meant to make you anxious. He said: ‘Honestly, people are so conditioned in this world that they feel obliged to say they loved it!’ It’s absurd, but it tells you a lot about the artificial distance we keep up with the audience.

The problem is that we’ve accepted the idea that classical music is for a minority. That it’s normal for it to reach only a few initiates. It makes me think of an interview with Benjamin Zander, conductor of the Boston Philharmonic. He described being in a meeting with other music directors. They were saying: ‘If we can raise the share of Americans who go to classical concert halls from 3 to 4%, we’re saved, we can keep working.’ And he exclaimed: ‘How can you say that? Why not aim for 100% of people?’

That’s the crux of the problem. In France, there’s no longer any music education worthy of the name in schools. The role of the conservatoires is to conserve, to train performers to perpetuate a tradition. Most teachers don’t even dare talk about composition, it has become so sacred. Even they don’t dare talk about it! It’s quite mad when you know that music schools used to teach improvisation.

Renaissance professional singers improvised complex polyphony on the spot, fugues in several parts. Improvised! And we don’t even dare step off the page any more. It’s regression, pure and simple.

Fortunately, there are people who break the mould. When I see someone like Jacob Collier getting his audience to sing, it speaks to me. All right, he isn’t the first: Bobby McFerrin was already doing it before him. But there’s something in it that, for me, is about communion with the audience. We make room for them beside us, on stage.

In the same spirit, I recently discovered the ensemble Les Apaches, who often team up with DJs to make electronic music with live performers. It’s absolutely wild. I saw them in a project where the kick drum was played on a contrabassoon. Resolutely modern music, but made by people who are walking encyclopaedias of music and who keep that popular streak in the noblest sense of the word. That’s what I call breaking the mould without lowering the bar.

Because that’s what I stand for, in the end. Music that gives up neither quality nor accessibility. Music that doesn’t hide behind intimidating codes to justify its elitism. I know a lot of people are irritated by the idea that classical music could be accessible to everyone. They prefer to carry on making music that isn’t for everyone, and that’s fine. What I’m saying is that I do something else. And even if it makes me look like a philistine, I don’t care.

I live for those concerts with people who have never heard a cappella music and who think: ‘That’s it? It’s incredible what you do with your voices!’ So many times I find myself in concerts with people who have never heard polyphony, who don’t even know what it is.

That discovery, that surprise, that sudden wonder: that’s real democratisation. Not grand statements of intent, not ‘beginners’ special’ concerts where everything is explained before a note is played. No, it’s going where people don’t expect us, offering them our music without presenting it as something complicated or intimidating. Just: this is what we do, this is what we love.

When I discovered composers like Jake Runestad or Eric Whitacre, I felt I could breathe again. At last, contemporary music that wasn’t trying to prove to me how learned it was! At last, modern harmonies that moved me without my needing an instruction manual! These composers understood that you can belong to your time without being impenetrable.

Take Whitacre’s Lux Aurumque. It was written in 2000; it’s music of today. But it speaks to you immediately. Those shimmering clusters, those suspended harmonies that seem to float in the air… The first time I heard it, I knew I wanted to sing it. And the first time I had a choir sing it, I watched singers discover that you can make contemporary music without hurting your ears.

The book

Du choriste au chœur

A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.

Discover the book

That’s what makes me angry, deep down. This idea that you have to pick a side. Either you do dusty classical music for the nostalgic, or you do incomprehensible contemporary music for the intellectuals. Nothing in between. As if there weren’t a whole generation of composers writing for today in today’s language, while keeping the ambition to move people, to bring them together, to make something beautiful.

Because that’s what it comes down to, isn’t it? Making something beautiful. Not something complicated, not something trendy, not something revolutionary. Just something beautiful. Something that lifts you, carries you away, creates a bond between people. Something that makes you think, as you leave a concert: ‘That was good. That did me good.’

I think back to a story a choir director friend once told me. He was conducting an amateur ensemble in a small provincial town. One evening they were giving a concert with a programme of traditional songs and a few tonal contemporary pieces. In the audience was an elderly gentleman who clearly wasn’t a regular at classical concerts. At the end, he went up to the director and said: ‘Sir, I came because my daughter sings in your choir. I know nothing about this music. But tonight I understood why she loves it.’

There you have it. ‘I understood why she loves it.’ Not: ‘That was very technical.’ Not: ‘What virtuosity!’ No. He had grasped the essence of the thing. The pleasure, the beauty, the joy of singing together.

That’s what I want to stand up for. The simple idea that classical music can be popular without betraying itself. That it can evolve, renew itself, welcome new audiences without losing its soul. That it can be accessible without being simplistic, modern without being elitist.

Classical music is alive. It is still being written, still reinventing itself, still speaking to us. So let’s stop mummifying it in a museum. Let’s let it be popular without that being a dirty word. Let’s let it touch, move and bring people together. That’s what it’s for, isn’t it?

Maybe I’m dreaming. Maybe I’m naive. But I still believe there is room for a classical music that is alive, open and generous. A music that isn’t content to rehash the past but keeps building itself, surprising us, moving us.

A music that owns being popular. Without that being a dirty word.

I don’t know if I’m right. I don’t know if my vision is the right one. But I do know that when I see singers discovering a composer they didn’t know, when I see their eyes light up the first time they hear a piece that surprises them, I tell myself we’re on the right track.

Popular classical music isn’t an oxymoron. It may even be its future. A future in which it is no longer the preserve of a cultural elite but the living heritage of everyone who loves to sing, loves to listen, loves to be moved.

A future in which it no longer hides behind intimidating codes, but offers itself simply and generously to anyone willing to lend it an ear.

Corentin

P.S. If this piece speaks to you, if you believe as I do that we can keep a popular, generous classical music alive, you can support this work by making a donation to the association. Every gesture counts in helping projects like AEVUM to keep existing and to keep surprising people.