There is a sentence I hear in almost every workshop, said apologetically, often with a little laugh: on my own, I can’t sing.
It comes from people who have sometimes been singing for twenty years, who hold their part in an eight-voice motet, who can read music, who sing in tune. And who, if you ask them to produce three notes on their own, go white.
This isn’t modesty. It’s the logical result of a practice. A choir singer learns to sing in a row, which means never being solely responsible for the sound.
That is the beauty of choir, and it is also its blind spot. And summer, precisely because nobody is listening, is the only time of year when you can look it in the face without any risk.
What the row takes from you without telling you
Singing in a choir is an exercise in constant adjustment. You make a sound, you hear it blend into everyone else’s, you correct. Your voice never exists on its own, it always exists in relation.
That is what makes choir so moving, and it is also why, after years, many choir singers have no idea what sound they are actually making.
The row offers three kinds of protection. It covers you: if you are slightly out of tune, the section absorbs it. It carries you: if you hesitate, the others hold the line and you catch up. And it takes the responsibility off you: the result is collective, so never quite yours.
These three protections are precious. They are also the reason a choir singer can sing for ten years without ever discovering they have a beautiful voice, or without ever discovering they push.
Du choriste au chœur
A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.
Discover the bookWhat happens when you take the row away
The first time you sing alone, something unpleasant and universal happens: you hear yourself. Really hear yourself. No mask, no blend, nothing to absorb it. And what you hear, almost always, you don’t like.
It matters to say so, because most people stop there and conclude that they can’t sing on their own.
In fact, they have just discovered their voice as it is, and the shock isn’t a verdict on quality, it’s a shock of unfamiliarity. You’re simply not used to it, that’s all. Nobody likes their voice the first time they hear it on an answerphone either.
The second thing is more interesting: the body stiffens. Without the row to carry you, you tighten, you push the voice forward, you try to guarantee the note instead of letting it come.
And that stiffening produces exactly what you were afraid of: a narrow, slightly hard sound, which confirms the belief you started with. The circle closes.
Why summer changes everything
Because the only thing stopping a choir singer from singing alone isn’t technique, it’s the witness.
In rehearsal, there is always someone. The section, the person conducting, the twenty pairs of ears beside you. Singing alone in front of them means exposing yourself, and exposure makes you tense.
In July, in an empty house, on a footpath, in a parked car, there is no witness any more. For the first time, you can make an ugly sound with no consequences.
And that is exactly the point. The right to make ugly sounds is the entry ticket to any vocal progress. A choir singer who never allows themselves an ugly sound will never find a new sound, because every new sound goes through an ugly phase. In summer, that right costs you nothing.
How to go about it, in practice
Don’t start with a difficult piece, and above all not with the solo you never dared ask for.
Start with something you know by heart, a piece from your June programme, so thoroughly learnt that you no longer have to think about the notes. It’s the only way to keep your attention free for what matters: sensation.
Sing it all the way through, at a medium volume, without trying to do it well. Then start again, changing just one thing: softer. Then once more, exaggerating the consonants.
Then once more, walking. You are not working, you are exploring. They are two different activities, and choir singers almost never do the second one.
If you want to go further, record yourself, just once, with your phone two metres away. Listen the next day, not the same day. The absolute rule: look for one single thing you like.
Not three things to correct. One thing you like. The opposite reflex is so strong that you have to force yourself, and yet it is the only kind of listening that builds anything.
What you bring back in September
Not a soloist’s voice. That isn’t the point, and most of you don’t want to sing alone anyway, which is perfectly legitimate.
What you bring back is information: you know what you sound like. And a choir singer who knows what they sound like adjusts differently.
They stop hiding behind their neighbour, they dare a dynamic, they hold their line when the section wavers. Without thinking about it, they become the person the others lean on.
A choir isn’t twenty voices dissolving into one another. It’s twenty voices that know who they are and choose to tune to one another. That’s a different thing altogether.
Have you ever sung alone, really alone? Tell me in the comments how it felt the first time.
Share your thoughts on this article