A few weeks ago, I received a message that touched me deeply. A singer told me she didn’t dare join the vocal ensemble in her town because she couldn’t read music. ‘I sing out of tune the moment I see a score,’ she wrote. ‘And yet when I hear a piece on the radio, I can sing it back without any trouble.’
Perhaps you recognise this. That little voice whispering that you don’t belong because you can’t sight-read fluently. That you ought to learn to read music first before taking the plunge. That ‘real’ musicians all read perfectly.
What if we turned that idea completely on its head?
Your ear: the instrument you already have
When you sing in the shower the tune that’s been running through your head since this morning, what exactly are you doing? You’re reproducing pitches, rhythms and nuances that your ear has picked up and memorised. You adjust instinctively when you feel it sounds wrong. You naturally find the emotion of the piece.
All of that is already music. Living, spontaneous, heartfelt music.
Reading a score is something else. It’s a code, a handy tool for passing on information. But between you and me… have you ever seen anyone fall in love with a tune by looking at notes on a stave? I never have. We fall in love with a tune by hearing it.
Your ear isn’t a second-class instrument waiting for music theory to approve it. It is your main instrument. And like any instrument, the more you use it, the finer it becomes.
The fear of singing out of tune that paralyses us
‘But what if I sing out of tune?’ That’s the question that comes up most often. As if singing by ear automatically meant singing roughly.
Yet let’s look at it another way. When you speak, you constantly adjust your intonation without thinking about it. You know instinctively that your voice goes up when you ask a question and comes down when you state something. You automatically adjust so that people can hear you in a noisy place, and you whisper in a quiet one.
All of that is already accuracy of pitch. A dynamic, living accuracy that adapts all the time.
In singing too, the ear can make tiny adjustments. It perceives harmonic tensions and feels when two voices lock perfectly into each other. It even develops that fascinating ability to anticipate where the tune is going, to guess the logical continuation of a musical phrase.
I remember a rehearsal where we were working on a motet by Poulenc. One of our basses, who didn’t read music, was the first to notice that we were drifting slightly out of line towards the end. ‘Something isn’t sitting right,’ he told us. He was right. His ear, free of any visual reference, had picked up an imbalance that we, bent over our scores, had missed.
Learning by listening: a dying tradition?
In the history of music, singing by ear is nothing unusual. For centuries it was actually the norm. Baroque singers ornamented their melodies by instinct, adding flourishes as the inspiration of the moment took them. They improvised within a style, granted, but they improvised.
Even today, in jazz, traditional music and gospel, people learn first by listening, imitating and making the music their own. They develop that precious ability to feel music from the inside, to understand it on its own terms rather than through an external code.
You’ll say: ‘Yes, but in a classical choir you have to follow the score!’ Of course. But there are a thousand ways of making it your own. Some people go through a visual analysis of the notes. Others listen to their part on a loop until it sinks in. Others again lean on the harmonies to find their own melodic line.
No method is better than the others. They complement each other.
The superpowers of a musical ear
When you develop your listening, you discover abilities you never suspected. For example, the knack of identifying your role in the whole. Are you singing the main tune? A countermelody? A bass line supporting the harmony? Your ear knows, even if you can’t name the exact chord that’s ringing out.
There’s also the ability to grasp the structure of a piece without looking at the score. You feel that a climax is coming, that the bridge is about to end, that the chorus is coming back. Your ear anticipates and prepares you for changes of energy, intensity and colour.
And then there’s that direct connection with the emotion of the piece. When you aren’t focused on sight-reading, you immediately pick up the expressive intention. You know instinctively whether to sing more gently or more firmly, whether the passage needs restraint or momentum.
Du choriste au chœur
A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.
Discover the bookDeveloping your ear, in practice
Want to sharpen your listening? Here are a few ideas, simple and hassle-free.
Listen to yourself sing. Record yourself now and then on your phone. Not to judge yourself, but to hear your voice ‘from the outside’. You’ll discover things: that little hesitation you didn’t feel, that note you dragged slightly, that phrase that sounds particularly good. It’s valuable feedback.
Sing without a reference instrument. Every so often, have a go without a piano or a backing track. Start in whatever key comes to you naturally and see where your ear takes you. You may find that your natural range isn’t quite what you thought.
Listen to the other sections. In rehearsal, when it isn’t your turn to sing, prick up your ears to the other voices. Try to understand how your line fits with theirs. This all-round listening greatly enriches your sense of the whole.
Work in small doses. Rather than trying to learn your whole part in one go, isolate the passages that give you trouble. Listen to them on a loop, sing them under your breath in the shower, hum them as you walk. Your ear will gradually get used to the intervals and remember them naturally.
Experiment with tiny adjustments. When you sing with others, have fun changing your pitch, your tone or your intensity very slightly. You’ll feel how these small changes affect the overall balance. It’s fascinating and very instructive.
When the ear guides technique
One of the most striking things I’ve observed is how much the ear can correct technique. I’ve seen singers instinctively adjust their vocal placement, their breathing, their resonance, simply because they could hear that ‘it sounded better like that’.
Your ear knows how to recognise a balanced sound. It perceives when the voice is well supported, when the resonators are working in harmony, when the articulation is clear without being forced. It guides you towards a better placement, often more effectively than a series of technical instructions.
Of course, technique still matters. It gives you tools, reference points, ways of being more precise. But technique without the ear is like a satnav without a destination. It tells you how to do things, but not always why, or what to aim for.
The ear gives you your bearings. It tells you: ‘There, that’s beautiful. There, it’s ringing. There, it’s moving.’
The freedom of looking up
Do you know what changes when you dare to look up from the score? Everything. First, your connection with the conductor. You pick up their intentions live, their last-minute adjustments, their invitations to expression. You follow their breaths and anticipate their gestures.
Your relationship with the other singers changes too. You hear them better, and you fit more instinctively with their breaths, their attacks, their dynamics. You develop that closeness that turns a group of singers into a true choir.
And then there’s a different kind of presence. When you’re no longer absorbed in reading, you fully inhabit your singing. You can play with colours, explore emotions, take expressive risks.
Does that mean we should throw away all our scores? Of course not. But perhaps we can see them differently. As a starting point rather than a constraint. As an invitation to explore rather than a strict set of instructions.
The art of natural memorisation
How do you remember a piece without learning it by heart mechanically? The ear has its own strategies.
First, it spots the structure: the phrase that comes back, the motif that develops, the chord progression that leads you home to the tonic. It identifies landmarks: the higher note that marks the climax, the falling line that announces the end of a section.
It also links the tunes to the words, when there are any. Not just their meaning, but their sound, their natural rhythm, their stresses. It turns these links between text and music into solid anchors for the memory.
And little by little, it weaves a web of connections that makes the piece familiar, predictable, habitual. You know what comes after a given passage, you anticipate a particular change of harmony, you feel a modulation approaching.
That is what we call making it your own. The piece becomes a little bit yours. You carry it inside you differently from a sequence of notes you have learnt.
Beginners have a head start
Paradoxically, people who come to choral singing without any previous musical training sometimes have an advantage. They approach music without preconceptions, without the slight tension that can arise from the clash between what you read and what you hear.
Their listening is fresh and open. It lets itself be surprised, moved and guided. It develops that precious ability to trust musical instinct.
I’ve seen beginners naturally take on subtleties of interpretation that experienced readers took a while to grasp. Simply because they were listening without a filter, without a ready-made analytical grid.
So if that’s you, don’t see your ‘lack’ of training as a handicap. See it as a richness to cultivate. Your ear is fertile ground, ready to welcome every discovery.
Du choriste au chœur
A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.
Discover the bookTowards richer listening
In the end, what really counts? Being able to name intervals, or feeling them? Identifying chords, or inhabiting them? Sight-reading quickly, or singing with soul?
I’m not saying you have to choose. The two approaches can live side by side and enrich each other. But perhaps we can reverse the order of priorities. Put the ear at the centre, and see music reading as a useful extra rather than a prerequisite.
Your ear already tells you so much. It can recognise the beauty of a chord, the emotion of a tune, a choir singing in tune together. It guides you towards what sounds right, what rings, what moves.
Trust it. Develop it. Refine it. Not to replace the score, but to go beyond it. To go past the notes towards what truly makes music: shared emotion, a common vibration, that mysterious alchemy that turns individual voices into a choir.
And if the singer who wrote to me reads this, I’d like to tell her: join that choir. Your ear is already your greatest asset. Your ability to sing back by instinct the tunes you hear is exactly what a choir needs. You’ll bring that freshness, that spontaneity, that true listening which is sometimes missing in people who get lost in the notes.
You’ll learn to read music as you sing, if you want to. Or not. What matters is that you bring your voice, your ear, your natural musicality. Everything else is a bonus.
Music is waiting for you. It has never asked for an entrance qualification.
Corentin
Share your thoughts on this article