When your choir’s repertoire seems too difficult or too easy, you have more room for manoeuvre than you think. Faced with a piece that’s too hard, you can change the way you work between rehearsals and tell your choir director. Faced with a piece that’s too easy, you can shift your standards towards what the score doesn’t show: the sound, the listening, the support you give your section. Changing choirs only becomes the right answer when the gap persists over several programmes.
This is the fourth article in the series on finding the right level in a choir. The first three looked at the question from the conductor’s podium. This one changes sides.
Is it the piece, the choir, or me?
Before concluding that a repertoire doesn’t suit you, you need to know what you’re talking about. Three very different situations produce the same feeling.
In the first, the piece is difficult for everyone. The whole choir is struggling, the director goes over the same passage every week, nobody is comfortable. That isn’t your personal problem, it’s a collective challenge, and it’s met collectively.
In the second, the piece is badly written for the voice. We talked about this in ‘Why some scores are so hard to sing’: some very beautiful pieces are conceived as if at the keyboard, and their lines are hard to sing even for seasoned singers. If you always stumble over the same leap, in the same place, it may not be your fault.
In the third, it’s you who are out of step with the group, above or below. That’s the only situation that calls for an individual response. And to recognise it, the level scale presented in the first article of the series is a good starting point: try to place the choir, then place yourself, criterion by criterion.
When the repertoire is too difficult for you
The first reflex is often to keep quiet and follow your neighbour. That works for a while, then it wears thin, because you end up permanently half-singing, never really knowing what you’re doing.
The first thing to change is the work you do between rehearsals. Not necessarily more work, different work. Listen to your line on its own, on a loop, until you can hum it without any support. Many choirs provide practice tracks for each section, and if they don’t exist, your director can often make them or point you to a recording. Ten minutes a day on your line alone is worth more than an hour on the whole piece.
The second is where you stand in the row. Singing next to a solid singer from your section changes everything: you hear your line instead of only hearing your own voice, and you breathe with someone who knows where they’re going. Asking to change places is nothing to be ashamed of; it’s a technical request.
The third is to talk about it. Your director doesn’t always know who’s losing the thread, especially in a large section. Telling them exactly where you get stuck (this leap, that entry, that fast passage) gives them information they don’t have. They may be able to rework the passage, adapt a note, or simply reassure you by telling you the whole section stumbles in the same place.
And there’s one thing people forget: the right not to sing everything. In some very exposed passages, it’s better to stay silent for a bar than to sing out of tune with conviction. That isn’t giving up, it’s a contribution to the sound of the group.
Du choriste au chœur
A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.
Discover the bookWhen the repertoire is too easy for you
Boredom in a choir is quieter than difficulty, and more insidious. You don’t mention it, you feel a bit guilty for feeling it, and it ends up turning into distraction, lateness, leaving.
The first thing to know is that a piece whose notes you know isn’t a finished piece. Knowing your notes is the start of the work, not the end. There’s still the sound: does your voice blend into the section, or does it stick out? There’s still fine tuning: is your third really placed in the chord, or only roughly? There’s still the phrasing, the dynamics, the ends of phrases, the way you hold a silence. A singer who’s bored by a simple piece can almost always find months of work in it, as long as they shift their attention.
The second is to become a support. A singer who’s comfortable in a section has a responsibility they didn’t choose: the others take their cue from them, whether they like it or not. Taking on that role consciously (singing clean entries, breathing visibly, holding the pitch when the section sags) is demanding and fascinating work. Being the person the others lean on is one of the rarest skills in a choir.
The third is to look for a challenge elsewhere, without leaving your choir. A workshop, a small vocal ensemble on the side, singing lessons, learning to read music. Many singers are very happy treating their main choir as a place of pleasure and connection, and find the technical challenge in another activity.
And here too, talk about it. Offering to help a section, to prepare practice tracks, to take on a passage as a soloist or in a small group, gives your director solutions rather than complaints.
When should you change choirs?
A programme that’s too easy or too difficult happens to everyone, and it doesn’t justify leaving. The repertoire changes every season, sometimes every term, and the piece that’s crushing you today will be replaced by another.
The question really arises when the gap lasts. When, programme after programme, you spend rehearsals just surviving, or when, season after season, you haven’t learnt anything new. Then it’s no longer a question of the piece, it’s a question of fit between you and the group, and looking for a better-suited ensemble is neither a betrayal nor a failure.
I’ve written a whole article on this decision, ‘Changing choirs: summer is the only time the question really arises’. What the level scale adds is a way of looking more effectively: instead of looking for a better choir, you look for a choir whose level matches yours on the criteria that matter to you.
A choir singer isn’t a consumer of repertoire
Ultimately, how you experience your choir’s repertoire depends largely on the position you take within it. A singer who waits to be given the right piece puts up with the programme. A singer who works on their line, helps their section, says what isn’t working and suggests what might work is taking part in the programme, even if they didn’t choose it.
The last article in the series tackles the most common situation of all, the one that makes everything above so complicated: the choir where the beginner and the seasoned singer sing in the same section.
Until then, a question for you: at the moment, does your choir’s repertoire seem too easy, too difficult, or just right? And what makes you say so? Tell me in the comments.
Share your thoughts on this article