There’s a thought that crosses many choir singers’ minds in August, usually in the evening, and that we chase away at once because it feels a little shameful: am I going back.

Not am I going to stop singing, no. Am I going back, there, to that particular choir, the Tuesday-evening one, the one I’ve been in for six years.

This thought never comes in October. In October the programme is under way, people are there, the December concert is getting closer, and the question no longer exists.

It can only surface in August, in the void, when habit stops deciding for you. That’s precisely why it deserves a proper look instead of being swept aside.

Habit is a very poor argument

Many choir singers stay in their ensemble for a reason they don’t dare admit to themselves: they’re already there. The journey is familiar, the faces are familiar, their place in the row is secured. Leaving would take effort, an awkward explanation, and the risk of ending up somewhere worse.

That isn’t an illegitimate reason. Loyalty to a group is a fine thing, and a choir isn’t a service you consume. But it isn’t an answer either.

Staying out of comfort and staying out of desire produce the same attendance on a Tuesday evening, and yet they make for completely different years.

So let’s ask the real questions, the ones we never ask because they’re uncomfortable.

The book

Du choriste au chœur

A kind, supportive guide for anyone who wants to grow as a choir singer without betraying who they are. In French for now; the English edition, From Singer to Choir, is coming in 2027.

Discover the book

The three signals that count

The first: did you learn something this year? Not won a concert, not had a nice evening. Learnt. Was your voice doing something in June that it wasn’t doing in September?

If the answer is no two years running, it’s not a disaster, but it is information. A choir that no longer helps you progress can still be an excellent choir, and become a club for you.

The second: are you happy to go, or relieved when it’s cancelled? It’s a brutal test and it never lies. Everyone has tired evenings when a cancellation is good news. But if relief has become the dominant feeling, you need to look it in the face.

The third, and the most important: does the repertoire still speak to you? A choir is first and foremost a musical project. If you spend half the season singing pieces that leave you cold, no amount of warm atmosphere will make up for it in the long run.

This is something choir singers are far too patient about. We put up with three programmes that don’t move us, telling ourselves the next one will be better.

What changing choirs won’t fix

Let’s be honest in the other direction too, because the fantasy of the better choir is powerful and often false.

If you’re bored because you never practise between rehearsals, you’ll be bored elsewhere. If you think the standard is low but you don’t know your part, the problem isn’t the standard.

If you haven’t spoken to anyone at the break for four years, another choir won’t make you more sociable. Changing ensembles only solves the problems that come from the ensemble.

And there’s one thing we always underestimate: what we lose. Six years in a choir means landmarks, trust, people who know how you sing and who carry you without you even noticing. That isn’t rebuilt in a term. You have to really want it.

The third way, the one nobody considers

Between staying passively and leaving, there’s an option almost no choir singer considers: staying and changing something.

Ask to change section or your place in the row, which radically changes what you hear and therefore your whole experience. Suggest a piece.

Ask whoever conducts for some time working on a specific point that has been holding you back for two years. Volunteer for something, the logistics of a concert, recruitment, anything that turns you from a consumer into an active participant.

A large part of the weariness people feel in a choir doesn’t come from the choir, it comes from the position they occupy in it.

We’ve settled into a passive role, held it for six years, and we blame the group for a boredom we built ourselves. Changing your position within the same choir is very often enough to get everything going again.

And if you leave, leave properly

If the decision is made, do it in September, not in January. A choir builds its season around its numbers. Leaving in the middle of a programme puts whoever conducts and your section in a real bind, and you’ll leave with a bad taste that will spoil six good years in hindsight.

Say it simply, in person if possible. No long explanatory email, no elaborate justification. Thank you for these years, I need something else, I’m leaving with no bitterness. Three sentences. People take them very well, much better than a silence and an empty chair in October.

And if you stay, stay for real. Decide it, don’t just put up with it. The same year awaits you, and it won’t be the same thing at all.

Have you ever asked yourself this question in August? Tell me in the comments how you settled it.