Last winter I came out of a sacred music concert feeling as though I had survived an endurance test rather than lived through a musical moment. Three hours on our feet in a stone church where the temperature hovered around 8 degrees, singers whose teeth chattered between pieces, voices growing hoarse as the hours went by. And there I was, wondering: why exactly do we do this?

Don’t get me wrong. I love sacred music, I’ve spent my life in churches, and I know that some constraints are part of the deal. But that night, watching a 70-year-old singer swaying on her feet, hearing the voices darken and tighten as the cold settled in, I told myself it was perhaps time to question that sacrosanct tradition of ‘we do it the way we’ve always done it’.

That evening haunted me for days. Not because of the music, which was beautiful, in spite of everything. But because of the strange feeling that we were all acting in a play. The heroic choir singer who endures anything for art. The sympathetic audience admiring our devotion. The conductor upholding tradition at all costs. Everyone playing their part, and nobody willing to say the emperor had no clothes.

In the choral world there is a kind of misplaced pride in suffering for art. As if enduring difficult conditions added nobility to what we do. ‘That’s authenticity,’ you hear. ‘The monks sang in the cold, didn’t they?’ Except that the monks, precisely, had their habits, their routines, their fireplaces, and above all they didn’t bring in 200 people from outside to listen to their office in spartan conditions.

I’ve conducted quite a few concerts in heritage venues, and I’ve seen this logic at work dozens of times. The venue dictates everything: the time, the temperature, the length, the position. Never mind if the voices tire, if the singers suffer, if the acoustics become unmanageable when everyone is shivering. ‘That’s how it has to be done,’ full stop.

But who decided that authenticity necessarily had to come through discomfort? Who decreed that a standing concert was always better than a seated one? And above all, who can honestly claim that a choir fighting the cold and fatigue sounds better than a relaxed choir focused on the music?

What fascinates me is how natural this logic of ordeal has become. We accept it without a murmur, as a rite of passage. Worse, we sometimes turn it into a selling point. ‘Come and hear this exceptional concert in the authentic setting of an unheated twelfth-century church!’ As if discomfort were a guarantee of artistic quality.

Let’s talk technique for a moment. Cold contracts the muscles, dries out the mucous membranes and reduces the flexibility of the diaphragm. Standing for three hours puts the whole weight of the body on the legs, creates tension in the back and alters the posture. The result: after an hour, half the choir is thinking more about their aching feet than about the subtleties of Palestrina.

And then there’s this strange logic that says we should ‘adapt’ to difficult conditions rather than improve them. As if it were a sporting challenge. ‘You’ll see, after three hours you can’t even feel your feet!’ Brilliant. Exactly what we’re after when we make music.

I remember a concert where I’d had discreet chairs placed behind the singers. Some of the audience thought it was ‘a shame’, as if something essential had been lost. And yet the voices were freer, the entries more precise, and nobody spent the evening wondering whether they would last until the end.

At the church in Auteuil, I experienced the absolute opposite of that logic. Officially, they had ‘forgotten’ to switch the heating on. In that gigantic church, we had to wait for the audience to arrive before the space began, timidly, to warm up. We froze through the entire dress rehearsal, in December. Not a gesture, not an apology, not even a ‘sorry, we didn’t think of it’. As if our comfort wasn’t part of the equation.

And then there was that evening at the auditorium in Aulnay, where a singer was taken ill during the concert. The heat was overwhelming, the air unbreathable. She collapsed between two pieces. By the time we had helped her up and she had come round, she went back to her place for the next piece. And then she was taken ill again. This time she collapsed in the middle of singing. What struck me most wasn’t so much her distress as that stubborn determination to ‘hold on at all costs’. As if giving up, even for medical reasons, were an admission of weakness.

At the other extreme, I’ve sung in sports halls on the edge of the Bassin d’Arcachon in the height of summer. Fifty degrees, stormy weather, the atmosphere of a sauna. There too, the same relentless logic: the venue has been chosen, the programme is fixed, we adapt. Never mind if we’re dripping with sweat onto our scores, if the voices go husky in the humidity, if the discomfort becomes palpable. The show goes on.

That anecdote made me think about our relationship with performance. What is so fascinating about watching musicians suffer? Why do we feel that a performance becomes more ‘real’ when it visibly costs the performers so much? Perhaps this is the heart of the problem: we have turned the concert into a show of endurance.

The audience, without realising it, becomes complicit in this staging. It admires our endurance as much as our art. It feels privileged to witness something exceptional, difficult, rare. And we choir singers feed that expectation by accepting conditions we wouldn’t tolerate in any other context.

Imagine asking orchestral musicians to play for three hours standing in the cold. Or actors to perform while shivering. There would be an outcry, and rightly so. But we choir singers find it normal. Worse, we are sometimes proud of it.

This complacency about discomfort reveals something deeper about our status in the musical world. As if, to be taken seriously, we had to prove our devotion through suffering. As if our art weren’t strong enough to stand on its own.

Because yes, let’s talk about the audience too. Who decides that listeners want to watch singers suffer? Who imagines that a concert becomes more beautiful when you see the performers battling the elements?

I’ve been to too many concerts where the musicians’ discomfort became the listeners’ discomfort. Where attention was split between the beauty of the music and concern for those poor singers who were visibly struggling. An audience that is cold, that can see we’re cold, that wonders whether everything is all right, is an audience that drifts away from the musical experience.

And then there’s that recurring argument: ‘But a standing choir is more impressive!’ Really? More impressive than what? Than a seated choir singing in tune, together, with all the energy and concentration it needs?

The impact of a concert doesn’t come from the apparent difficulty of the exercise. It comes from the truth of the interpretation, the communion between the musicians, that mysterious alchemy that makes a moment unforgettable. And that can happen sitting, standing, warm, cool, in pyjamas if you like.

This obsession with appearance, with visible spectacle, troubles me deeply. It betrays a distrust of the music itself, as if it needed an extra dose of drama to move people. As if Bach or Palestrina weren’t powerful enough to captivate without the help of extreme conditions.

There is something perverse in this logic that links suffering with artistic quality. Something that reminds me of those old clichés about the tormented, misunderstood artist who can only create in pain. Except that here we’re not talking about creation, we’re talking about performance. And performance demands availability, concentration, freedom. Not endurance.

This mentality has concrete consequences for the way we work. How many rehearsals have I seen where the singers didn’t dare ask for a break, a chair, a bit of heating? How many times have I heard ‘It’s fine, I can manage’ when the person was visibly in difficulty? This culture of silent sacrifice poisons our practice.

I’ve seen 70-year-old singers forced to hide a chair on stage, for fear of disapproving looks. As if sitting down amounted to betraying the collective commitment. This symbolic violence inflicted on the most fragile makes me furious. We turn an activity that should bring joy into an endurance test.

And yet I’ve experienced the exact opposite. Concerts under the bridges of Paris, in jeans and a simple white shirt, with our water bottles in full view. We chatted with the audience between pieces, we laughed, we created a direct human connection. The emotion came across infinitely better than in those rigid masses where everyone plays their part without daring to breathe.

Chilly Gonzales once said that ‘musicians who want to impress rather than touch people should go to musical prison’. That line always makes me laugh, but it hits the mark. It reminds us of something essential: what is the point of making music if it doesn’t create a connection? If our priority becomes performance, virtuosity or respect for rigid codes, to the point of losing contact with the people listening to us? Don’t we sometimes impose constraints on ourselves that, instead of serving the art, take us further from it and, above all, further from the audience?

This question of ‘who are we doing this for’ runs through our whole world. Recently I posted on Facebook the idea that you could sing in a choir without having mastered music theory. You can’t imagine the reactions! Ayatollahs of music theory who consider that anyone daring to sing sacred music without flawless sight-reading deserves to be stoned. As if the beauty of singing had to come first through the suffering of rigid learning.

This mentality reveals something deep about our relationship with musical pleasure. Does work necessarily mean self-denial? Must we flagellate ourselves when we get something wrong? I’m not so sure. I’ve sung barbershop, where the tradition of ‘tags’ means meeting up in a café and spontaneously singing the endings of songs. Two or three tags like that, for your own pleasure and for the others who get to enjoy it. It’s done in a spirit of generosity, not performance.

In fact, more and more often on social media you see international a cappella groups singing seated. In auditoriums, in churches, in cafés. They are completely at ease with this relaxed posture, and nobody finds it any less impressive. On the contrary, it gives off an ease, a confidence that serves the music.

And what about conductors in all this? Some seem to take a perverse pleasure in keeping conditions difficult, as if it were a test of motivation. I’ve seen music directors flatly refuse any adjustment, in the name of some kind of artistic purity. As if purity meant making your musicians suffer.

This attitude often reveals a confusion between artistic rigour and organisational sadism. A good conductor knows how to tell the difficulties that serve the music from those that harm it. They know that singers who are fit, relaxed and focused will always produce a better result than singers fighting exhaustion.

But some also have this fear of looking ‘soft’ if they suggest adjustments. As if providing chairs or heating meant giving up their authority. It’s exactly the opposite: a real leader knows how to create the best possible conditions for the team to give their best.

Personally, I’ve never said ‘stop’ outright in an absurd situation. But I stopped going to projects where I knew things would go badly. Where I could sense the boredom, the pointless discomfort, that mentality of ordeal. I learnt to spot the people who have this rigid attitude towards classical music. The ones for whom suffering is part of the artistic contract.

I think back to that 70-year-old singer I saw swaying. What must she have been feeling? Shame at showing her fatigue? Guilt at no longer being able to keep up like the young ones? The sense of letting the group down by visibly suffering? This symbolic violence inflicted on the most fragile makes me furious.

Because, deep down, this logic of ordeal is profoundly unequal. It favours the young, the sturdy, those with the health to take it. It quietly excludes everyone else: older people, those with back problems, circulation problems, chronic fatigue. It turns the choir into natural selection.

We pretend not to see it, but we all know it: some ‘heroic’ concerts effectively push out some of our fellow singers. The ones who won’t come back after suffering in silence. The ones who would rather give up than go through that ordeal again. And we lose voices, experience, human diversity, in the name of what? A misunderstood tradition.

This selection by exhaustion reminds me of what I experienced in certain ‘elite’ choirs. Brilliant people, technically flawless, who had so internalised this logic of constant effort that they had lost all spontaneity. They sang in tune, but without soul. They followed every instruction, but you could feel they no longer truly inhabited their voices.

In contrast, at my concerts under the bridges, I saw complete beginners discover the pure pleasure of singing in harmony. No stress, no pressure, just the simple joy of blending your voice with others. The result was sometimes technically rough round the edges, but the emotion was there. The audience could tell, and so could we.

This makes me question our relationship with age in choral singing. Why do we so readily accept that getting older means having to prove you can still ‘keep up’? Why not adapt our practices so that experience counts for more than endurance? Mature voices bring an irreplaceable richness to our ensembles. Losing them over idiotic questions of image is an artistic waste as much as a human one.

There’s also a gender dimension we avoid naming. Women often take it in silence. They have learnt not to complain, to grit their teeth, to smile even when it hurts. How many times have I seen women singers hide their exhaustion for fear of looking like wimps? This demand for stoic performance weighs differently depending on whether you’re a man or a woman.

And then there’s the economic question, which is rarely raised. Many amateur singers juggle their passion with constraints of time, money and transport. Asking them on top of that to endure difficult conditions adds a physical and mental cost that can become prohibitive. We risk turning choral singing into a hobby for the privileged, for those who can afford to suffer for art.

So no, I’m not saying we should ban all standing concerts or avoid chilly churches. I’m saying we need to stop confusing respect for tradition with collective masochism.

Authenticity means first of all respecting the music and the people who make it. It means creating the conditions for the art to express itself fully. If a venue, a position or a length prevents that, then we need the courage to question them.

I’ve conducted seated concerts of incredible intensity, and standing concerts that dragged on because everyone was exhausted. I’ve sung in heated churches where the voices soared, and in freezing cathedrals where even the toughest among us ended up forcing.

Tradition is precious. But when tradition becomes a straitjacket that stops the music from breathing, then we have to be willing to let it evolve.

What saddens me is this tendency to sanctify our constraints. To turn our difficulties into virtues. To make people believe that the harder it is, the more beautiful it is. This logic of redemption through suffering has nothing to do with true art.

Musical beauty is born of freedom, of availability, of the ability to let the work flow through you. It requires relaxed bodies, focused minds, voices free of any unwanted tension. Anything that gets in the way of that availability harms the art, full stop.

Deep down, this obsession with formal authenticity often hides lazy thinking. It’s easier to reproduce the gestures of the past than to ask what they mean. It’s more comfortable to follow an established protocol than to reinvent our practices according to our needs today.

But true authenticity isn’t slavish imitation. It is faithfulness to the spirit of a work, to its deepest intention. And if that intention comes across better with modern adjustments, then those adjustments become more authentic than blind respect for old forms.

I think back to that failed concert in the freezing church. What exactly were we celebrating? Our capacity to endure? Our submission to convention? Our fear of questioning fixed habits? Certainly not the music of Palestrina, which deserved so much better than our tight voices and tired bodies.

The real revolution would be to dare to say: ‘This magnificent work deserves the best possible conditions to serve it.’ And if that means chairs, heating, breaks, adjustments, then let’s do it without any embarrassment.

Because in the end, what matters? That the audience leaves thinking: ‘They were brave to sing in those conditions’? Or that they leave deeply moved by the beauty of what they heard?

The answer ought to be obvious. But apparently, it isn’t yet obvious to everyone.

Ultimately, what strikes me in all this is our collective ability to normalise the abnormal. To turn dysfunctions into traditions. To pass off our discomfort as nobility. This distortion tells me something worrying about how we see ourselves and our art.

Because after all, if we so easily accept mistreating our bodies and voices in the name of tradition, what does that say about the value we place on ourselves? If we consider that our wellbeing comes second to respecting fixed forms, what image do we have of our status as artists?

There is a form of self-deprecation here that troubles me. As if we didn’t deserve the consideration naturally given to other musicians. As if our amateur status (in the best sense of the word) condemned us to accept what a professional would refuse outright.

This mentality holds our art back. It restricts our possibilities, limits our ambitions, discourages people of goodwill. It makes choral singing a niche activity, reserved for the stoical, when it could be open to everyone who loves music.

The irony is that this complacency about hardship undermines precisely what it claims to defend. It drives the audience away, wears out the performers, impoverishes the repertoire. It turns moments that should be pure aesthetic delight into endurance tests.

So what can we do? Start by recognising that we deserve better. That our art deserves better. That the audience deserves better. Recognise that intelligently adapting our practices is not a betrayal but a higher form of respect for the musical tradition.

And above all, dare to say no when it’s necessary. No to absurd conditions, no to pointless sacrifice, no to this logic of ordeal that confuses suffering with beauty. Saying no is sometimes the only way to say yes to what really matters: the music.


If you’d like to explore these questions of concert conditions and stage preparation further, my book ‘Du choriste au chœur’ covers all the practical aspects that make the difference between a successful concert and a memorable one. The book is in French; the English edition, ‘From Singer to Choir’, is coming in 2027.